Human Relations Commission
February 17, 2022 at 5:29 PM
- 1 h 26 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: February 17, 2022
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a virtual meeting on February 17, 2022. The session began with a roll call, during which it was noted that the Commission did not have a quorum until Councilwoman Rooney joined. With no formal votes taken and no public comments received, the meeting focused primarily on staff updates, presentations on city data practices, and progress reports from the Commission’s working groups.
A significant portion of the agenda was dedicated to an update on the City’s reparations project. Staff liaison Brenda Mills reported that interviews for 18 eligible applicants were completed on Tuesday. She also informed the Commission that the Boards and Commissions Committee will submit five recommendations for impact focus areas to City Council on the 22nd. Additionally, Mills introduced new staff members for the Office of Equity and Inclusion: Marcus Kirkman, Training Consultant; Alaina Schmidt, Analyst; and Darien Blue, Outreach Coordinator.
The Commission also reviewed a presentation by Eric Jackson, Manager, and Cameron Henshaw, Performance Analyst, from the Office of Data and Performance. The presenters outlined the mission of their office, which is less than one year old, and explained the City’s adoption of the "Results-Based Accountability" (RBA) framework to ensure equitable outcomes, accountability, and communication. Jackson emphasized the importance of feedback, stating, "Part of the culture change we're trying to bring is to welcome challenge. Because it's the only way we learn... Keep challenging us. Keep challenging the rest of city staff. That's actually the only way we're going to get the improvement that we need." Commission members subsequently asked questions regarding the equity of data collection, the role of the Office of Equity and Inclusion in data processes, and the inclusion of narrative data alongside numerical data.
Updates from the Commission’s working groups were also shared. Regarding Intergovernmental Relations, no action had been taken yet. Commissioner Harold reported working independently on notes for the Community Engagement group and expressed interest in coordinating with the group. On housing issues, Commissioner Noyes-Espinoza discussed the City’s search for a consultant to gather data on the houseless community, with a deadline expected in mid-March. She stated her intention to present information on "sanctuary camping" soon. Commissioner Venable reported that the group examining systems and improving the HRCA is currently observing city governance dynamics before taking action, noting a lack of in-person interaction due to the virtual format. Venable explained, "I just chose to sit back on this one and watch what was going on with some other things that's going on systemically within our city... It's better to see what is going on as far as the feel from our governing board."
The meeting concluded with a discussion on the return to in-person meetings. Councilwoman Rooney announced that City Council would meet in person on February 22. A staff member explained that advisory boards and commissions would begin phasing back to in-person meetings over the next couple of months, starting with City Council committees and statutorily required boards. The Chair noted that the Commission did not have a quorum initially but that the meeting proceeded with staff updates and presentations. The meeting was adjourned without a formal vote, as the Chair stated, "We do not need to call for a vote. If there is no other business, we will adjourn."
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Chair Rodriguez agreed to email Commissioner Harold after the meeting to set up a meeting to discuss his notes and develop actionable items for the Community Engagement working group. Staff liaison Brenda Mills agreed to send the presentation materials and contact information to the Commission members. Commissioner Noyes-Espinoza stated she plans to present information on "sanctuary camping" to the Commission in the near future. Additionally, staff indicated they will release a schedule to the public and board members as the phasing of in-person meetings is finalized.
Meeting Video & Transcript