Skip to main content
  • 1 h 27 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On March 9, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) held a virtual meeting to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (COAs) within historic districts and discuss the pre-application for landmark designation of the Walton Street Pool. The Commission also addressed administrative matters, including the timeline for the upcoming HRC Award and the formation of a nominating committee for the next fiscal year’s officers.

Key Decisions

The Commission voted to approve three COA applications, with all motions passing unanimously by a vote of 7 ayes.

  • 13 St. Dunstan’s Circle: The Commission approved the replacement of exterior vinyl siding, trim, and soffits with LP Shake Smart Siding in a smooth finish on a non-contributing structure in the St. Dunstan’s Historic District. A second motion was passed to issue the COA with the condition that the applicant provide section drawings for the siding reveal and door/window trim to staff for review and approval.
  • 134 Flint Street: The Commission approved after-the-fact changes to an accessory structure in the Montford Historic District, including a roof overhang, different entry doors, a new retaining wall section, and paving. A second motion was passed to issue the COA without conditions.
  • 101 Santee Street: The Commission approved the construction of a new two-story, 2,360-square-foot primary structure in the Montford Historic District. A second motion was passed to issue the COA with the condition that specifications for the mechanical unit be submitted to staff.

Discussion Highlights

Chair Emily Kite opened the meeting by reminding members that the HRC is a quasi-judicial body, emphasizing that they are applying historic district standards rather than soliciting public opinion on the desirability of applications.

Regarding the pre-application for landmark designation of the Walton Street Pool (Riverview Park), staff reported on the criteria for significance and the integrity of the structure. Commissioner Will Hornaday stated, "I thought it checked all the boxes for criteria for significance and aspects of integrity... It’s a lot more modest... and I think that’s what’s sort of important to show and remember and appreciate." Commissioner James Vaughn agreed with preserving the pool but noted, "I think we need to be mindful and sensitive about talking to the neighborhood community... so that the community feels like this was an act of historic preservation done with them, not done to them." Staff member Alex Smith added, "I do see this as an opportunity, maybe for some healing within the community, if there’s a way that we can really elevate and honor this special place."

In administrative matters, staff outlined the timeline for the HRC Award. Commissioner Gail Lazarus offered support for outreach efforts, stating, "Part of our role as historic resource commissioners... we have an education component... if there’s ways that we could be of service or help outreach or just be there to back you up, Alex, while you’re out there with your poster boards... we could be helpful too." Staff also noted the resignation of Commissioner Amanda Volras and the current vacancies for the City and County seats.

Follow-Ups

  • 13 St. Dunstan’s Circle: Staff member Alex Smith agreed to follow up with the applicants "hopefully before the end of the week, if not early next week" to assist with the required section drawings for the trim and siding reveal.
  • 134 Flint Street: Staff member Alex Smith stated, "I will follow up with you guys in the next few days."
  • 101 Santee Street: The applicant agreed to reach out to the builder to obtain mechanical unit specifications and submit them to staff, stating, "I will do that probably next week." Staff confirmed, "No hurry on our end."
  • Walton Street Pool: Staff member Alex Smith stated they would engage the community in March and April using visual aids and surveys. Staff also agreed to ask a colleague named Todd about mailing letters to the immediate community prior to the final public hearing.
  • Nominating Committee: Staff member Alex Smith agreed to circle back with Chair Emily Kite in the next couple of days to finalize the nominating committee for the next fiscal year’s officers.

Impact

These decisions allow property owners in the St. Dunstan’s and Montford Historic Districts to proceed with their respective construction and renovation projects in compliance with historic preservation standards. The discussion regarding the Walton Street Pool highlights the Commission’s focus on community engagement and the potential for the landmark designation process to foster community connection and preservation of local history.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches