Skip to main content

Historic Resources Commission

April 13, 2022 at 4:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 9 meetingNext: Nov 9 meeting
  • 1 h 51 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On April 13, 2022, the City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened to conduct quasi-judicial evidentiary hearings, review administrative items, and discuss community heritage initiatives. The meeting focused on three Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) applications for properties within historic districts, as well as the status of the City’s reparations commission and the selection of annual award recipients.

Key Decisions The Commission began by approving the minutes from the March meeting by a unanimous vote of 7-0. The body then reviewed and approved three CA applications, all of which passed by a unanimous vote of 7-0. For the Young Men’s Institute (YMI) at 39 South Market Street, a Local Landmark, the Commission approved work including awning relocation, roof replacement, and the addition of ADA-compliant walkways, with conditions requiring staff review of mortar, light fixtures, brick samples, and mechanical unit screening. For 295 Cumberland Avenue in the Montford Historic District, the Commission approved window and door modifications, a new shed dormer, and roof repairs, conditioned on revised elevation drawings and the preservation of the original window being removed. For 144 Flint Street, also in the Montford Historic District, the Commission approved a new gable dormer and the replacement of non-original doors and windows with no conditions. Additionally, the Commission approved the slate of executive committee officers, including Chair Emily Kite, Vice Chair Emily Sprang, Second Vice Chair Gail Lazarus, and Third Vice Chair Will Hornaday, by a unanimous vote of 7-0. Regarding the annual HRC Award, the Commission agreed to present two awards this year to Anne Chesky Smith, Director of the Western North Carolina Heritage Association, and the founders/caddies of the Skyview Golf Association at the Municipal Golf Course ("Muni"), though no formal vote was recorded.

Discussion Highlights The Commission heard a presentation from Brenda Mills, Director of the Office of Equity and Inclusion, regarding the status of the City’s reparations commission. Mills stated that the commission is preparing for an orientation meeting with the goal of completing orientations by mid-May and emphasized that the HRC is viewed as a partner in this process. Commissioner James Vaughn expressed concern that historic Black resources be considered during the reparations process, noting that while such input should ideally come from Black members of the community, he felt a responsibility to act as an ally given the current lack of Black representation on the commission. During the review of the 295 Cumberland Avenue application, Chair Emily Kite noted that the proposed shed dormer looked "a little bit out of whack" and suggested that pulling in the roof overhang edges might improve its consistency with the rest of the house. Regarding the HRC Award, Chair Kite indicated support for creating different types of awards to accommodate both nominees.

Community Input A public commenter asked for clarification on whether the reparations presentation was part of the quasi-judicial proceedings. Chair Kite and staff clarified that the presentation was advisory and informational, not part of the quasi-judicial hearing process. No public comments were recorded for the three CA applications.

Follow-ups Staff member Alex Smith agreed to follow up with the applicants for the YMI, 295 Cumberland Avenue, and 144 Flint Street projects the following week to address conditions and outstanding details. Smith also stated she would send out details regarding the return to in-person meetings in May, including parking information, and would work with Pack Library special collections staff to create a display explaining the renaming of the HRC Award (formerly the Bristow Soundly Award). Commissioner James Vaughn stated he would present the award to the Muni golfers and caddies at the Griffin Awards event on May 26, while Commissioner Emily Sprang stated she would present the award to Anne Chesky Smith at the same event. Chair Emily Kite stated she would also attend the event and potentially participate in presenting the awards.

Impact These decisions allow for the continued preservation and adaptive reuse of historic properties in Asheville, balancing safety and accessibility improvements with the maintenance of architectural integrity. The approval of the YMI project includes specific conditions to ensure that new materials and mechanical installations are reviewed for compatibility with the landmark structure. The selection of two recipients for the HRC Award highlights the Commission's commitment to recognizing diverse contributions to the city's heritage, including both institutional preservation efforts and community-based cultural practices at the Municipal Golf Course.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches