Skip to main content

City Council Work Session – March 8, 2022

March 8, 2022 at 2:20 PM

  • 1 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Work Session Recap: Open Space Zoning Amendments

The Asheville City Council held a work session on March 8, 2022, to review staff-proposed amendments to the city’s zoning text regarding private open space regulations. The discussion focused primarily on changes to residential, commercial, and River Arts District zoning standards, as well as related zoning map amendments. As this was a work session for information and discussion, no motions were made, and no votes were taken.

Staff presented data indicating that current open space requirements serve as a significant barrier to infill housing. Citing the "Bowen Report" and White House research, staff argued that reducing open space mandates could increase housing supply, which is linked to addressing affordability and racial wealth gaps. The Planning Director, Todd Ocleancheany, stated, "Housing production has not kept up with the increasing population growth, and that alleviating supply constraints would have a significant impact on the racial wealth gap." A staff presenter, Della Safika, added, "Our currently our open space standards... are a significant obstacle to infill housing... the current ordinance is severely broken and undermining infill development."

The proposed changes include a tiered system for apartments and condos, reducing the current requirement of 500 square feet per unit or 15% of the parcel to 10–15% depending on design quality. For residential subdivisions, staff proposed reducing the current 20% open space requirement, with an alternative option for developers to increase tree canopy preservation instead. For commercial sites over one acre, the proposal requires 50% open space unless developers voluntarily implement advanced stormwater mitigation measures, a workaround intended to incentivize better stormwater management on large sites. Additionally, staff proposed strengthening open space standards in the River Arts District by reducing building coverage from 80% to 7% to preserve floodplain areas adjacent to the French Broad River.

Council members raised several points of concern during the discussion. Council Member Sage Turner expressed worry about the complexity of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), stating, "I have this growing concern that we are staff piecemeal updating our UDO to the point where it is more challenging and therefore expensive to develop... I would love to hear maybe... are we planning to update a UDO in a comprehensive way?" However, Turner also expressed support for the process, saying, "I don't want us to stall anymore. I'm in support of moving forward... I applaud you for going to these eight boards and commissions." Council Member Kim Roney questioned the affordability thresholds, noting, "80% AMI, it seems once again that we're not going to get to our goals if we're leaving it that high. I'd like to see something closer to 60." Mayor Esther Manheimer highlighted confusion regarding the stormwater incentive, stating, "I think we've got a little confusion and our messaging around stormwater... I think we need to try... to clarify some of that."

Staff explained that the proposals resulted from a consensus-based process involving an Open Space Task Force composed of eight boards and commissions. Two boards, the Urban Forestry Commission and the Neighborhood Advisory Committee, voted not to support the current draft due to concerns about gentrification and tree loss. Staff clarified that the open space amendment does not override the separate tree canopy preservation ordinance, though a subcommittee is working on improved citywide tree and landscaping standards that may be presented alongside or after this amendment.

In response to Council concerns, staff agreed to specific follow-up actions. The Planning Director stated, "We could definitely clarify that messaging on our website and in further presentations that we give," addressing the confusion regarding the stormwater incentive. Additionally, when a Council member suggested combining the open space changes with new tree and landscaping standards to address concerns, a staff member responded, "We could do that... we could be prepared to do that if that's our direction."

No formal public comments were recorded, as the Chair stated, "today just like with any work session we don't take public comment." Staff confirmed that the item will return to the Planning and Economic Development Committee for further review, potentially in May or June. Following that, the item is scheduled for a Planning and Zoning Commission hearing in July and a City Council public hearing in the summer.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches