Public Safety Committee
February 25, 2022 at 10:30 AM
- 1 h 50 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On February 25, 2022, the City of Asheville Public Safety Committee convened to address three primary agenda items: public comment on encampment removal policies, the purchase of a mobile command bus, and an update on Asheville Police Department (APD) traffic stop data. The committee’s only formal vote was to approve the minutes from the previous meeting via roll call. No votes were taken on the mobile command bus, the 24-hour encampment notice policy, or traffic stop procedures, as these items were presented for information sharing and discussion.
Key Discussions and Decisions The committee reviewed a proposal for a $1 million mobile command vehicle intended to serve as a central office and conference space for multi-agency incidents, such as major fires or bridge collapses. Fire Department staff noted the vehicle has a 20-year lifespan, and City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized the urgency of the purchase due to current supply chain constraints. However, no vote was taken on the purchase at this meeting.
Regarding APD operations, the discussion focused on the rationale for shifting from a seven-day to a 24-hour notice for encampment removals and data regarding racial disparities in traffic stops. APD Captain Mike Lamb defended the 24-hour notice policy by citing high victimization rates within encampments, noting that while the homeless population represents 0.5% of the city, they account for 20% of victims in violent crime. APD Crime Analyst Doug Osier defended the department’s data methodology, clarifying that the analysis used a sample of 44 highly visible locations. Chief David Zak stated that the APD does not intentionally target specific races or genders for traffic enforcement and announced the rollout of the "Lights On" program for minor vehicle violations.
Community Input Residents raised significant concerns during public comment regarding the encampment policy. Commenters argued that the shift to a 24-hour notice was made without public input in a closed meeting in spring 2021, is inhumane, and is based on flawed data. One commenter presented a slide deck arguing that citywide crime rates are declining and that the correlation between encampments and crime is misleading, stating, "Our unhoused population is not responsible for a wave of crime across the city." Another commenter highlighted a severe shelter shortage, noting only about 10 beds were available citywide with strict requirements, and asked, "When moved, where are people to go?" Vice Mayor Smith acknowledged these concerns, noting they would be addressed by Chief Zak regarding operational procedures.
A public commenter also criticized the APD’s inconsistent quarterly reporting on traffic stops since 2020 and the lack of data on the city website. They noted that in 72% of investigatory stops, no action or only a warning was issued, arguing these interactions pose risks to residents. Vice Mayor Smith responded by inviting continued conversation on the best uses of traffic stops, distinguishing between community-building presence and profiling, and stating, "I don't, I'm not really sure that we have substantial consensus on whether the use is necessary or just another profiling tool."
Follow-up Actions Several staff members and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Deputy Fire Chief Chris Baczynski agreed to provide a deeper analysis on usage and cost-sharing possibilities with other jurisdictions before the mobile command bus purchase is finalized. City Staff Emily Ball agreed to share updates on point-in-time count data regarding why individuals are not in shelter, noting that local data would be available shortly. Chief Zak agreed to reach out to state troopers for more information regarding a sustained effort of traffic stops on the south side of the city, which he stated he was previously unaware of. Additionally, Councilwoman Roney requested a scheduled follow-up for the March agenda regarding Asheville Housing Authority eviction filings and the end of Code Purple and Ramada shelters; Vice Mayor Smith suggested this might be better suited for the Housing Committee, but Roney clarified she expected a data analysis and plan for the March Public Safety Committee meeting.
Impact on Residents These discussions highlight ongoing tensions between public safety enforcement and social services in Asheville. The debate over the 24-hour encampment notice reflects broader community concerns about the treatment of the unhoused population and the availability of shelter resources. Meanwhile, the review of traffic stop data addresses resident concerns about police interactions and racial equity. The potential acquisition of the mobile command bus aims to improve coordination during major emergencies, though its final approval is pending further analysis on cost-sharing.
Meeting Video & Transcript