Skip to main content
  • 2 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: January 25, 2022

The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee convened on January 25, 2022, to address public safety operations, transportation franchises, and recent incidents. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of a pedicab franchise agreement, updates on fire department investigations and police staffing, and a follow-up on the December 2021 Aston Park arrests. The meeting began and ended with extensive public comment sessions.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously voted to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Additionally, the committee unanimously voted to recommend that the franchise agreement for "Blue Ridge Rickshaw" be moved to the full City Council for review and approval. No votes were taken on the Fire Department Investigation Program Update, APD Staffing and Recruitment, or the Aston Park Incident Follow-Up, as these were informational presentations.

Discussion Highlights Regarding the pedicab franchise, Councilwoman Roney expressed concern that advisory boards should ideally navigate such issues before they reach the committee, though she voted to recommend the agreement to the full council. City Attorney Brad Branham clarified that franchise agreements require two separate readings by the full council and noted that the committee’s recommendation would allow the Multimodal Transportation Commission to provide its recommendation, scheduled for January 26. Director of Transportation Ken Putnam confirmed the agreement would be presented to the Multimodal Transportation Commission on that date.

On fire safety, Senior Deputy Fire Marshal Bill States reported that the department determined the origin and cause of fires 84.5% of the time, a 13% increase. Fire Marshal Kelly Hines noted that restructuring and coordination with the Asheville Police Department (APD) have increased the closure of criminal fire investigations. Vice Mayor Smith requested a comparison of fire investigation data over a six-month timeline rather than a year to better assess the effectiveness of the restructuring.

Police Chief David Zach presented an update on officer attrition, noting that while APD is budgeted for 238 sworn positions, only 179 are currently staffed. Accounting for leave, only 133 officers are available for daily duty, representing a 44% reduction in sworn strength. Janae Toon of Epic Recruitment Solutions, a new contractor, emphasized the need to build trust within the agency and community. Councilwoman Roney expressed concern that the recruitment strategy does not align with Asheville’s history or community values, arguing that resources are being hoarded for policing rather than diversified into broader public safety responses.

In the follow-up on the December 2021 Aston Park arrests, Deputy Chief Mike Yelton stated that six individuals were arrested for refusing to leave the park, none of whom were homeless, and affirmed that all actions were warranted and legal. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated she could not determine the distinction between a journalist and a participant, expressing confidence that officers made the correct legal distinctions. City Attorney Brad Branham noted that while journalists are covered under the Privacy Protection Act of 1980, they are not immune from following reasonable police instructions or abiding by laws such as trespass.

Community Input During the opening public comment session, a representative from East West Asheville criticized the lack of advanced publication of APD presentation materials and requested mandatory advanced document publication for future meetings. They also urged the committee to question APD’s actions in Aston Park regarding the seven-day notice for camps and journalist arrests. A West Asheville resident expressed concern that new bureaucratic processes for feeding the unhoused would reduce aid and urged the city to follow CDC guidelines regarding camp dispersal during winter and the pandemic. No committee members responded to these opening comments.

During the closing public comment session, multiple commenters expressed alarm at recruitment imagery featuring officers with semi-automatic rifles and military gear, questioning the strategy of "recruiting children" into policing. Representatives from Food Connection and a farm worker spoke against a proposed ordinance restricting food sharing in public parks, arguing it would criminalize mutual aid and misuse strained police resources. Other commenters questioned the city’s liability for arresting journalists and expressed frustration that the city was "kicking down the doors of trust." One downtown resident expressed support for APD and requested the removal of Councilwoman Roney from the committee, while another commenter, a City Council candidate, expressed outrage at the "social experiment" of policing. No committee members responded to these closing comments.

Follow-ups Staff indicated they would need time to gather the six-month fire investigation data requested by Vice Mayor Smith. No other explicit follow-ups were agreed to by members or staff at this meeting.

Impact This meeting highlights significant challenges in public safety staffing, with APD reporting a 44% reduction in daily available sworn officers. The decision to send the pedicab franchise to the full Council initiates the formal approval process for a new transportation service in Asheville. Furthermore, the discussions on the Aston Park arrests and police recruitment reflect ongoing community debate regarding the role of law enforcement, the treatment of journalists and unhoused individuals, and the allocation of public safety resources.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches