Skip to main content

Boards & Commissions Committee

February 8, 2022 at 10:18 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jan 11 meetingNext: Mar 8 meeting
  • 28 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On February 8, 2022, the City of Asheville Boards and Commissions Committee convened to address staffing vacancies for several advisory bodies and to review the status of annual reports. The agenda focused primarily on the selection process for the new Impact Focus Area Commission, appointments to the Human Relations Commission, and the re-advertisement of positions for the African American Heritage Commission.

Key Decisions The committee made three primary decisions during the session. First, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to move all applicants for the Impact Focus Area Commission forward for full council interviews. Second, the committee voted unanimously (3-0) to appoint Amanda Benson-Bremseth and Michael Brown to fill two vacancies on the Human Relations Commission (HRCA). Third, after staff reported that none of the three applicants for the African American Heritage Commission were city residents, the committee decided to re-advertise the position.

Discussion Highlights Staff presented data indicating that out of 2,518 total applicants for the Impact Focus Area Commission, 18 were city residents, 6 were county residents, and 1 was ineligible. A staff member, Ms. Jones, described the provided scoring rubric as a "strictly optional" tool designed to help council members make informed decisions based on eight factors, including expertise in impact areas, personal impact from systemic racism, and residency length. When asked how to weight interviews against written applications, Ms. Jones suggested using the same rubric for both and taking the "highest score, whether it's from the interview or the review of the application" to account for potential bias in how candidates present themselves in different mediums.

Regarding the HRCA, staff identified Amanda Benson-Bremseth and Michael Brown as the only two eligible city residents after determining that one applicant was a county resident. For the African American Heritage Commission, staff reported that none of the three applicants met the residency requirement. In a broader comment on the role of these bodies, Councilwoman Kim expressed gratitude for the volunteer boards, stating, "I am just really incredibly grateful that we have so many volunteers who bring their professional experience to advise us on our budget plans and policies." She emphasized the importance of public engagement efforts by these groups.

Follow-ups Staff member Sarah agreed to follow up with boards and commissions that did not submit their annual reports by the January 31 deadline. Additionally, Sarah agreed to check applicant availability for a proposed Tuesday afternoon interview slot (February 15, 1:00 PM–5:00 PM) and report back if an alternate day, such as Monday morning, is needed to maximize participation. Ms. Jones requested that the council share the names of unselected candidates with the commissioners so they may also consider them, noting the goal is to have one appointee per impact focus area.

Impact These decisions establish the next steps for filling key advisory roles in the city. By moving all eligible Impact Focus Area Commission applicants to the full council for interviews, the city ensures a broader pool of candidates is considered for the new commission. The appointment of Benson-Bremseth and Brown fills the current vacancies on the Human Relations Commission, allowing that body to continue its work. The decision to re-advertise the African American Heritage Commission positions ensures that the city seeks candidates who meet the specific residency requirements for that body.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches