Skip to main content
  • 45 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On January 11, 2022, the City of Asheville Boards and Commissions Committee convened to review board appointments, discuss committee restructuring, and approve previous meeting minutes. The meeting was chaired by Vice Mayor Smith. The agenda focused on filling vacancies across multiple city boards and commissions, reviewing demographic data for board members, and updating internal processes for application reviews.

Key Decisions and Votes

The committee began by unanimously approving the minutes from the November 9 meeting (3 Ayes, 0 Nays). The majority of the meeting was dedicated to voting on appointments for various boards and commissions. The committee unanimously voted to recommend or appoint the following individuals:

  • Affordable Housing Advisory Committee: Matthew Bartholomew
  • Board of Adjustment: Michael Luciano
  • Civic Center Commission: John Pierce
  • Downtown Commission: Robin Rains and Guillermo Rodriguez (reappointments), and Ricardo Sejo and Tal Frankfurt (new appointments)
  • Metropolitan Sewage District: Derek Weekly
  • Riverfront Redevelopment: Kate Kiah
  • Urban Forestry Commission: Amy Smith (reappointment) and Zoe Hoyle (new appointment)

For the Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and Environmentals, the vote was not unanimous. Councilwoman Roney voted "No" (Nay), while Councilwoman Roney and the Chair voted "Aye" (2 Ayes, 1 Nay). The motion to reappoint Chris Pelrine and Anna Priest and to recommend the appointment of Michael Toten passed.

Two items were postponed rather than voted on:

  • Homelessness Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC): The committee postponed consideration of appointments until they learn more about the proposed restructuring of the committee.
  • Human Relations Commission: The committee agreed to postpone the appointment and re-advertise the position to allow the commission time to make a formal recommendation based on their recent retreat.

Discussion Highlights

Staff presented a proposal to restructure the HIAC to comply with regulatory requirements and expand public input. The proposal involves formalizing the HIAC as the HUD Continuum of Care governance structure and creating a broader "Homelessness Alliance" for general membership. Staff member Brian Husky noted that the city is the only continuum of care in the nation where the governance body is solely political appointees, which limits input from stakeholders, including people of color and those with lived experience of homelessness. Husky emphasized the vital role of the current representative with lived experience, stating, "I think I probably benefited far more from that interaction in a sustained and meaningful and really deep way than he did. But boy, we would have been sunk without him this year." The committee unanimously voted to move this restructuring proposal forward to Full Council for adoption.

Regarding the Sustainability Advisory Committee vote, Councilwoman Roney explained her "No" vote by stating, "I just happened to have been, because I felt that this recommendation was amongst the strongest recommendations we received. And since they recommended Kara Spiano, I had been inclined to go with Anna Preece, Chris Pelline, and Kara Piano. So my note is because I wanted Kara included based on the strong recommendation for her."

The committee also reviewed the 2021 Demographics Report presented by the Deputy City Clerk, Sarah Gross. Gross noted that 22% of board members identified as Black or African American, which is 4% higher than the previous demographics report for 2020. Additionally, staff member Jerry Goldberg updated the committee on a new searchable document format for applications. Councilwoman Roney thanked staff for this change, stating, "an end result of this is now it's more accessible for copy and paste, which means it's more accessible for translation services, it's more accessible for low and no vision readers. So I think we've done a great service to our community."

Follow-ups

  • HIAC Restructuring: Staff members Brian Husky and Nikki Reed stated they will get the proposal in front of Full Council "as soon as we possibly can."
  • Human Relations Commission: Staff will re-advertise the vacancy to allow the commission time to make a formal recommendation based on their recent retreat.
  • Annual Reports: Staff member Sarah Gross stated that annual reports for boards and commissions are due January 31, 2022, and will be compiled into one report for the next meeting in February.
  • Application Process: Staff member Jerry Goldberg noted that the new searchable document format for applications is now in use to improve accessibility and save resources.

Impact

These decisions ensure that city boards and commissions are filled with new and returning members who will advise the city on issues ranging from housing and urban forestry to sustainability and downtown development. The restructuring of the HIAC aims to create a more inclusive governance structure that better represents the community, particularly those experiencing homelessness, by moving away from a solely political appointment model. The updated application process and demographic reporting aim to increase accessibility and transparency in how the city selects and monitors its advisory bodies.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches