Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
February 3, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 2 h 1 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee held a virtual meeting on February 3, 2022. The session focused on procedural updates, staff reports regarding the local housing inventory, and a detailed policy discussion on the feasibility of manufactured housing within city limits.
Key Decisions The committee took four formal votes during the session. First, a motion to approve the timestamped minutes passed with 10 ayes and 1 abstention. Second, a motion to formally request a joint meeting with the Housing and Community Development (HCD) department passed unanimously. Third, a motion to add a rental report update to the monthly agenda passed unanimously. Finally, a motion to create a future agenda item to bring in Planning, Zoning, and DSD staff to discuss how the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and zoning restrict housing options—including manufactured, tiny, and park model homes—passed unanimously.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the severe shortage of affordable housing. Data presented indicated that at one point in the month, there were zero single-family homes under $275,000 available in Asheville. In contrast, 32% of closings under $275,000 in Buncombe County were manufactured homes, compared to only 1% in the city. Chair Barry Bialik presented this data and asked the committee to explore recommending the allowance of manufactured homes in the city. Member David Bartholomew stated that failing to explore the most affordable housing options at this time would be "inexcusable" and "very irresponsible." Member Scott Adams noted that regulations around manufactured housing are "classically classist and exclusionary," while Member Brian Methvin emphasized the need to keep pace with emerging technologies like modular units.
Staff also reported on ongoing staffing shortages, noting that the affordable housing officer position is in HR processing and that Sasha Vertunsky is serving in an interim capacity. Significant frustration was expressed regarding the lack of clear direction from the HCD department and the slow progress on key projects. Member Margie Bukowski expressed concern over the 319 Biltmore property, stating, "We spent 5.3 million to buy 319 Biltmore, and there’s nothing being built on it yet." Member Paul Heathman added, "It’s hard enough to get people to participate in government... And it just looks really, really bad... I hope I sure hope that we can get some progress and get back on track."
The committee also examined the Housing Trust Fund, with staff noting a current working balance estimate of $2.3 million. Staff member Nikki explained the need for a strategic framework rather than focusing solely on the current number, stating, "I really want to provide a little more framework and context around that... so that we can be strategic about investments... rather than zeroing in on a number." Additionally, the group discussed a discrepancy between the committee’s description on the CD website and its bylaws, with Member Andy Barnett noting that the website description focuses only on the supply side and excludes demand-side strategies.
Follow-ups Staff member Nikki committed to sharing updates when the job description for the affordable housing officer is ready and posted. Nikki also committed to providing a robust update on the 319 Biltmore and Deaverview projects within 60 days. Staff will attempt to obtain updates on the Lot Star project and the paused Cobin event for the next meeting. The committee agreed to discuss the appointment of a secretary for internal notes outside of the meeting to bring a plan to the next session. Furthermore, the committee will work toward scheduling a joint meeting with HCD to clarify goals, timelines, and the committee’s role, and will schedule a future agenda item to discuss zoning restrictions on housing types with Planning, Zoning, and DSD staff.
Impact This meeting highlighted the critical gap in the city's affordable housing inventory, specifically the near-total absence of single-family homes under $275,000. By voting to explore manufactured housing and zoning restrictions, the committee is addressing the structural barriers that limit low-cost housing options in Asheville. The decision to request a joint meeting with the HCD department aims to resolve the lack of clear direction and slow project progress that has frustrated committee members and residents alike.
Meeting Video & Transcript