Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
January 6, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee held a virtual meeting on January 6, 2022. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates on departmental staffing and data initiatives, and a review of ongoing housing-related task forces and legislative items.
Key Decisions
The only formal vote taken during the meeting was to accept the minutes from the previous session. A motion was made and seconded, and all members in favor raised their hands, resulting in the approval of the minutes. No other formal votes were cast regarding staffing changes, the housing moratorium, or the Open Space Amendment; these items were discussed for status updates and input only. The meeting was adjourned without objection.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to an update from Nikki, the Director of Community and Economic Development (CED), regarding a restructuring of the department to better address affordable housing priorities. The department is being reorganized into four focus areas: Community Development, Affordable Housing, Equitable Economic Development, and Continuum of Care. Key changes include the creation of a new senior-level "Affordable Housing Development Officer" position to oversee the Affordable Housing Bond program, down payment assistance, and other incentives, as well as a support role for an "Affordable Housing Development Specialist." The former Community Development Program Director, Paul D’Angelo, has left the city, and his previous duties are being split between the new Community Development Division Manager and the new Affordable Housing Development Officer. Jonathan Jones has been asked to serve as the interim Community Development Division Manager while the position is advertised.
The committee also heard a presentation from the Office of Data and Performance (ODAP), presented by Eric Jackson, Natalie Bailey, and Cameron Henshaw. ODAP outlined its mission to empower staff and community members to use data for decision-making, utilizing a framework called Results-Based Accountability (RBA). Current projects include integrating data into the city’s budget process, gathering baseline data for the upcoming Reparations Commission, and supporting data-based evaluation for American Rescue Plan funding.
Regarding "unfinished business," the committee discussed the status of the Open Space Amendment, noting that the task force’s recommendations were pulled from the Planning and Zoning agenda due to objections from the Urban Forestry Commission, the Coalition of Asheville Neighborhoods, and conflicts with a project at the Livingston Street Community Center. Chair Andy Barnett expressed frustration that the work done by staff and the task force was being set aside, stating, "It’s like it’s so frustrating for all the work staff has to put into these things. And then, like I said, when their papers get put back in the fan." Member Scott Adams also voiced frustration, noting he felt the time and interest invested in the issue were being disrespected. Additionally, the committee discussed a proposed housing moratorium; Chair Barnett expressed a desire for a high volume of applications to allow the city to select the best projects and update the housing trust fund balance, while Nikki confirmed that there has not been any guidance from the City Manager, meaning the city is still operating as usual.
Community Input
A public commenter, identified as a resident running for City Council, spoke regarding the Open Space Amendment. The commenter noted that their written comments appeared as a single block of text online without paragraph breaks and expressed concern that the task force process had faltered due to a lack of public advertisement and opposition from neighborhood groups. They emphasized that civic engagement must be attractive and well-communicated to be functional. Chair Andy Barnett acknowledged the comment, confirmed the committee had the full written text, and noted that the "Connect" task force is working on improving communication. Additionally, two written comments were received regarding poor maintenance management at Glenrock Apartments. Chair Barnett stated that he had personally forwarded these comments to a contact at Mountain Housing.
Follow-ups
Nikki, the CED Director, committed to finalizing job descriptions for the Affordable Housing Development Officer and Specialist and working with HR on salary ranges to ensure competitive hiring. She stated that the Community Development Division Manager position will be advertised "as quickly as possible." Nikki also agreed to place a future agenda item on the calendar to update the committee on the Housing Trust Fund balance and Bond dashboard. In response to a question about federal data, Nikki agreed to follow up on whether demographic data from CAPER reports could serve as a placeholder for equity data. Eric Jackson from ODAP stated that the office is working with the homeless initiative team to automate data reporting on the website, with an update expected by the end of the month or around April. Chair Barnett indicated that the committee would "watch" the situation regarding the moratorium over the next few months.
Impact
This meeting highlights the City of Asheville’s efforts to formalize its approach to affordable housing through specific staffing changes and data-driven performance metrics. The creation of a dedicated Affordable Housing Development Officer role signals a structural commitment to managing housing programs and incentives. The discussion on the Open Space Amendment and the housing moratorium reflects ongoing tensions between development goals, neighborhood concerns, and the administrative challenges of implementing these policies. For residents, the focus on data transparency through ODAP and the commitment to competitive hiring for key housing roles are intended to improve the efficiency and equity of city services.
Meeting Video & Transcript