Urban Forestry Commission
February 1, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 31 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: February 1, 2022
The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission convened on February 1, 2022, to review recent operational reports, address specific development requests, and discuss upcoming policy changes. The meeting included the formal introduction of new Commission member Zoe Hoyle, who is replacing Steve Hendricks. Hoyle expressed her enthusiasm for working with the Commission, noting that while she does not see herself as fulfilling the specific position of her predecessor, she is looking forward to the work ahead.
The Commission took several formal actions during the session. First, the body approved the minutes from the December meeting, incorporating a correction regarding the vote tally on the Open Space Amendment; all voting members voted in favor. Second, the Commission unanimously approved (7-0) an alternative compliance request for a project at 227 Haywood Road, allowing the developer to forgo planting street trees. Finally, the Commission unanimously accepted (7-0) its annual report, which was subsequently submitted to the City Clerk’s office. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to adjourn.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on a staff presentation regarding the proposed Open Space Amendment. Staff proposed allowing subdivision developers to choose between providing 10–15% open space or increasing tree canopy preservation by 10%. This proposal sparked debate regarding the trade-offs between paved open space and preserved trees. Staff member Vidilla Satnika from Planning and Urban Design stated that she believed more people would choose the tree canopy option, which would generally result in a greater amount of preserved trees. Commission member Perrin DeYoung cautioned the group about a "steady stream of misinformation" regarding the amendment, advising members to seek a second opinion before sharing information that favors the amendment. Chair Amy Smith emphasized the importance of civil discourse, stating, "I don’t want the loudest voice in the room to be the only voice that’s heard."
The Commission also reviewed the Tree Canopy Protection Ordinance (TPO) report and received a report on recent storm response efforts. These reports led to a discussion about the lack of a centralized database for tracking tree planting data across city departments. Vice Chair Dawn Chavez noted that the city does not have a single repository for tracking tree planting data and suggested it would be beneficial to have one where all departments can report activities. Additionally, Commission member Ed Macy commented that funding an urban forest master plan would enable the city to track not only trees being planted but also those being lost.
During the public comment period for the 227 Haywood Road project, a public commenter, who is the owner of the business "Story Parlor," spoke regarding the site. The commenter confirmed that she and her partner had purchased the building in December and noted that the strip of grass on the Howard Street side is often driven over by cars. Despite this, she expressed willingness to plant hardy ground cover there for beautification. In response, a Commission member suggested the applicant consider using that small strip of grass to plant perennials or other wildlife habitat food for pollinators, framing it as a "consolation prize" for the lack of street trees. The applicant agreed with the suggestion, acknowledging that the space is limited due to parking. No verbal public comments were made during the general public comment period, though staff clarified that two written comments related to the Open Space Amendment had been received late for the previous month’s meeting and were available for review in the documents folder.
Several follow-up actions were identified for the near future. Staff member Nancy Watford agreed to add a figure for expected future fee-in-lieu payments to the TPO report and stated that the Commission should determine what data they want to collect for their upcoming retreat. Regarding the Open Space Amendment, staff member Vidilla Satnika confirmed that a City Council open space public work session is scheduled for Tuesday, March 8, from 2:00 to 4:00 PM, and that the item will go to Planning and Zoning sometime in the spring. Staff member Ben Woody noted that the deadline for budget requests is February 18 and agreed to submit the request for an Urban Forester and Urban Forest Master Plan around that time, incorporating input from the Commission. Additionally, Nancy Watford and Chair Amy Smith agreed to provide a draft of the updated Rules and Procedures manual to Commission members in advance of the retreat. The Commission scheduled their annual retreat for February 22, from 1:00 PM to 4:30 PM, with the chair coordinating with guest speakers and city staff.
These discussions and decisions are significant for residents as they shape the city’s approach to urban forestry and land use. The approval of the alternative compliance for 227 Haywood Road sets a precedent for how street tree requirements may be handled in specific developments. The ongoing review of the Open Space Amendment and the push for a centralized tree data repository aim to improve the city’s ability to maintain, sustain, and grow its urban tree canopy. Commission member Patrick Gilbert noted that once these discussions are completed, they will have a profound effect on the city’s ability to manage its urban tree canopy throughout Asheville.
Meeting Video & Transcript