Urban Forestry Commission
December 7, 2021 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 21 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: December 7, 2021
The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission met on December 7, 2021, to address alternative compliance requests, legislative updates, and the commission’s annual planning. The meeting began with the unanimous approval of the previous month’s minutes. The agenda then moved to two requests for alternative compliance regarding street tree planting, both of which were approved. The commission subsequently engaged in an extensive discussion regarding the City’s proposed Open Space Amendment and the Tree Canopy Protection Ordinance, ultimately voting to oppose the amendment as currently written. The meeting concluded with updates on the department’s budget request, the election of officers for the coming year, and a resolution recognizing the service of former Chair Stephen Hendricks.
Key Decisions The commission approved two alternative compliance requests. For 39 South Market Street (Wyomai Cultural Center), the commission voted unanimously (7 ayes) to approve the request to plant one small maturing tree and exempt the second required tree due to utility conflicts and narrow sidewalks. For 172 South Charlotte Street (White Labs), the commission voted 5-2 to approve the replacement of existing multi-stemmed river birches with single-stemmed serviceberries. The vote was split, with ayes from Dawn Chavez, Cecil Bothwell, Steve Hendricks, Sharon Summerall, Patrick Gilbert, and Amy Smith, and nays from Perrin DeYoung and Ed Macy.
The commission also voted on a resolution regarding the Open Space Amendment. After debate, the commission voted 4-3 to approve a revised resolution of opposition to the Open Space Amendment as currently written. The ayes were cast by Perrin DeYoung, Cecil Bothwell, Sharon Summerall, and Amy Smith, while Steve Hendricks, Ed Macy, and Patrick Gilbert voted nay. Following this, the commission unanimously (7 ayes) voted to draft a letter of recommendations to City Council to accompany the resolution.
In other actions, the commission decided to hold its end-of-year lunch on December 13, 2021, at 1:00 PM at White Lab on Charlotte Street. The commission re-elected its current Chair and elected Dawn Chavez as Vice Chair, with both motions passing by roll call with all voting members voting "Aye." Finally, the commission adopted a resolution recognizing the service of former Commission member and Chair Stephen Hendricks by a vote of 6 ayes and 1 abstention (Hendricks abstained); this resolution will be forwarded to City Council.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the Open Space Amendment. Members debated its impact on urban canopy and housing affordability. Perrin DeYoung stated, "The cons are much greater than the pros from the standpoint of the urban canopy... The current iteration of the Open Space Amendment is incompatible with the protection and restoration of urban canopy in the City of Asheville." Cecil Bothwell added, "I find no basis on which we can approve the current open space amendment... If you can pave your whole damn parking lot and call that open space, that's not anything to do with saving the tree canopy." Conversely, Steve Hendricks argued, "We should write a letter to the city... recommending that they move with an urban forest master plan, green space planning, so that we have starting with an inventory and baseline... Right now it's just a big muddle mess kind of thing." Dawn Chavez noted, "Open space is not green space necessarily... The open space ordinance and amendment are not about tree canopy in any way... I think we do need greater clarity. More analysis needs to be done."
Regarding the tree replacement at 172 South Charlotte Street, City Arborist Mark Foster explained, "It's a stitch in time saves nine. It's the triple stem birches. That was the wrong tree for that location... It's going to be easier and less expensive and more seamless to replace them now than when they're, you know, 30 feet high." Perrin DeYoung offered a dissenting view, stating, "My suggestion is let's cross that bridge if and when we come to it. And rather than eliminating the existing vegetation we have for smaller vegetation that won't serve the same purpose for years... these trees stand, let's continue the pruning and let's see how they do."
The commission also discussed the budget request for an Urban Forester position. Ed Macy emphasized, "If we had to make a choice, the [Urban Forester] position is most important. It's the position that will manage development of the urban forest master plan. So you can't do one without the other." Assistant City Manager Ben Woody confirmed that this is the only staff request from the Development Services Department. Additionally, Patrick Gilbert provided a legislative update, noting, "The language that was in House Bill 496 that would prohibit municipalities... from enacting tree protection ordinances... was stripped out of the budget bill 105. So, that’s a good thing."
Community Input A public commenter stated that the Urban Forestry Commission should oppose the Open Space Amendment because its purpose is to protect existing trees. The Chair acknowledged receiving four emailed public comments that generally suggested the Commission oppose the Open Space Amendment, with one comment including additional suggestions regarding the tree canopy protection ordinance. The Chair responded, "I took all of those public comments very seriously... I do want us to do the best for the trees and for the community." The Chair clarified that the Commission had not taken a specific position on the amendment previously and that the current discussion was necessary to determine a stance.
Follow-ups Steve Hendricks agreed to develop a draft letter of recommendations to City Council, including points about the need for better impact analysis and an urban forest master plan, to be sent out by the end of the week. Kim Roney, the City Council Liaison, stated she would wait to prepare her liaison report to the full council until she receives the letter of recommendations from the Commission. The Chair stated she would meet with Chris Collins and other city staff the following day to review GIS parameters for the fee and lieu program and report back next month. Ed Macy suggested reconvening the policy committee with Chris Collins to revisit the Tree Canopy Protection Ordinance after the first of the year, which the Chair confirmed would be on the agenda for a retreat tentatively planned for the end of January. Patrick Gilbert agreed to clean up the document for Chapter 20 revisions to send back to the city for a second look. Ben Woody confirmed he will take information regarding the importance of the Urban Forester position to the department head budget retreat towards the end of the month. A staff member agreed to share specific bullet points on the urgency of the Urban Forester position and PowerPoint presentations with the group, while another staff member agreed to create a folder to house these materials. Patrick Gilbert stated he is waiting to hear back from Julie Mayfield regarding the status of House Bill 496. The Chair stated she is working on an outline of the year’s accomplishments and will send a draft to members for comments within the next week. The Chair also stated she will be in touch with possible dates for the annual retreat in late January.
Impact These decisions directly affect how the City manages its urban forest and responds to development. The approval of alternative compliance requests allows for specific site adjustments to street tree planting where physical constraints exist, such as utility conflicts or maintenance issues with multi-stemmed trees. The commission’s vote to oppose the Open Space Amendment signals a formal stance that the current language of the amendment may not adequately protect urban canopy, which will be communicated to City Council via the upcoming letter of recommendations. The push for an Urban Forester position and the completion of Chapter 20 revisions highlight the commission’s focus on establishing a dedicated staff role to manage the urban forest master plan and update local ordinances, aiming to provide a more structured approach to tree protection and green infrastructure in Asheville.
Meeting Video & Transcript