Skip to main content

Design Review Committee

January 20, 2022 at 12:29 PM

  • 2 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Recap: January 20, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Design Review Committee met virtually on January 20, 2022, to review administrative items, the committee’s annual report, three formal design reviews, and one informal design review. The meeting addressed projects in the downtown area, with a focus on compliance with the Downtown Design Guidelines.

Key Decisions and Votes The committee approved the minutes from the December 16, 2022 meeting by a unanimous vote of 5-0. One member noted they were not present at the original meeting but voted to approve the minutes. The committee accepted the annual report by consensus without a formal roll-call vote. For formal design reviews, the committee voted unanimously (5-0) to recommend approval for the renovation and expansion project at 48 South Market Street and the mixed-use development at 123 Haywood Street, finding both projects meet the intent of the Downtown Design Guidelines. Conversely, the committee voted unanimously (5-0) not to approve the large mixed-use project at 363 Hilliard Avenue as presented. The committee determined the project does not currently meet guidelines regarding facade width and rhythm for the Clingman and Hilliard Avenue elevations, and that the landscape and parking entrance on Hilliard Avenue are not appropriately screened. No vote was taken on the informal review for permanent pergolas at 7 Patton Avenue (The Eris Hotel).

Discussion Highlights During the review of 48 South Market Street, the architect explained that the existing brick on the front facade is painted and could not withstand sandblasting without deteriorating. Committee member Jeremy Goldstein stated, "I think it's a vast improvement over what's currently there." For 123 Haywood Street, committee member Steven Lee Johnson noted that the design team had carefully addressed previous feedback, stating, "I'm ready to vote to approve." Committee member Bryan Moffitt added, "I'm pretty excited at the way this process has unfolded. I feel like this building is way better than what they first came to us with."

The discussion on 363 Hilliard Avenue focused on architectural rhythm and site access. Committee member Bryan Moffitt expressed concern that the clean elevation "still reads like one big long building to me" and does not meet the intent of the guidelines. An applicant argued that the design creates "book in defects" and internal consistency, which they viewed as good architectural design. Committee member Jeremy Goldstein responded, "The rules, the downtown rules are pretty clear. And so, I mean, I just, they want you to break it up. So it looks like different buildings and it doesn't look that way now. It's that simple." Regarding the Eris Hotel pergolas, committee member Bryan Moffitt commented that the design looks like an "impermanent structure that's trying to be permanent," suggesting it needs to be one or the other. Committee member Kimberly Hunter raised concerns from an ADA function standpoint, noting the design creates more enclosed space with fewer visible ways to exit for safety.

Community Input A public commenter submitted written comments regarding 363 Hilliard Avenue, expressing concern about the driveway entrance on Hilliard Avenue, noting it is a key pedestrian street. A committee member expressed appreciation for the comment, noting they had missed it. Staff noted that the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) discourages entrances on key pedestrian streets if alternatives exist. The applicant argued the entrance is necessary for the success of the ground-floor retail. No public comments were received for the other agenda items.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to add an appendix to the annual report with direct links to the 15 projects reviewed to help City Council understand the volume of work. Staff also agreed to share the recommendation regarding a speed limit change on Clingman Avenue with the Transportation Director to allow for tree planting, though no update was received at this meeting. The applicant for 363 Hilliard Avenue stated they would like to return to the committee after the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting on February 2 to present revised plans addressing the committee’s concerns before the project goes to City Council. The committee agreed to delay the election of a Chair and Vice-Chair until March to allow for new appointments by City Council.

Impact These decisions affect the development of downtown Asheville. The approval of the 48 South Market Street and 123 Haywood Street projects allows these renovations and expansions to proceed, while the non-approval of 363 Hilliard Avenue requires the applicant to revise plans to address facade and screening issues before the project can move forward. The feedback on the Eris Hotel pergolas indicates that the current design requires modification to better integrate with the building’s architecture and address safety concerns.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches