Skip to main content
  • 1 h 45 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: February 17, 2022

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on February 17, 2022, to address administrative updates and review three development projects. The committee began by approving the minutes from the January 20, 2022 meeting, a motion seconded by a member and passed unanimously with five ayes. The committee also adopted revised rules and procedures to align its appointment process with a recently adopted City Council ordinance. These changes specify that all nine committee seats will be appointed by City Council, with three seats representing the Downtown Commission, three representing the Riverfront, and three at-large. This motion was seconded by Robin Raines and passed unanimously with five ayes.

The primary agenda included a formal Level 2 design review for the Star Building at 28 North Lexington Avenue, which proposes the historic rehabilitation of the structure into a 35-room hotel and retail space. Steven Lee Johnson moved to approve the adaptive reuse project as submitted, a motion seconded by a staff member. Robin Raines recused herself from the vote because the project was submitted through her firm. The remaining four members voted aye, resulting in a unanimous approval of the project. No public comments were received for this item.

The committee also conducted an informal design review for Create 72 Broadway, a proposed nine-story mixed-use building featuring an extended-stay hotel, residential condominiums, and retail space. The project sought to bypass City Council review. During this discussion, a public commenter via phone, an attorney representing property owners who utilize the alleyway behind the site, raised concerns regarding the proposed garage access. The commenter noted that the alley is narrower than the 20-foot minimum required by the Unified Development Ordinance in some sections due to deeded parking spaces and questioned the applicant’s legal right to use the alley for primary access. A staff member responded by confirming that the design assumes the ability to use the alley and stated, "I don't know that the alley has to be 20 feet wide... This is not a public road. Alleys can be less than that." The staff member suggested that the applicant’s attorney speak with the public commenter’s attorney to resolve the access issue.

Regarding The Avery at 363 Hilliard, the committee conducted a courtesy and informal review of a mixed-use residential development that had already been approved by Planning and Zoning. The committee was seeking feedback before a final City Council vote. Steven Lee Johnson moved to forward a favorable review to City Council and to publicly acknowledge the developer and design team for their collaboration. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously with five ayes. No public comments were received for this item.

In other business, the committee observed a moment of remembrance for a former member, with Robin Raines noting, "We lost a very valuable member of this committee... Karen Craig Nolan... Kimberly Hunter wanted to say a few words in honor of her." Kimberly Hunter added, "Karen was a phenomenal human who did some really powerful work in our community, especially and specifically to the River Arts area... We will miss her very, very much." Additionally, a staff member informed the committee that while City Council is returning to in-person meetings, boards and commissions will likely continue to meet remotely for at least another couple of months.

Several follow-up actions were established during the meeting. For the Create 72 Broadway project, the public commenter agreed to share deed information regarding the alleyway with the applicant’s team and staff. A staff member agreed to review this information and coordinate with the applicant. Furthermore, the design team for Create 72 Broadway requested to schedule at least one more informal review session, and a staff member confirmed the project was penciled in for another informal review in April. The committee also agreed to wait until the next meeting in March to elect a Chair and Vice Chair, allowing time for new appointees to join the committee.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches