Downtown Commission
January 14, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: January 14, 2022
The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission held a virtual meeting on January 14, 2022, to review development projects, finalize its annual report, and reestablish a committee for managing public spaces. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, reviews of two specific building projects, updates on upcoming design reviews, and a discussion on policy recommendations for City Council.
Key Decisions The commission took three formal votes during the session, all of which passed unanimously. First, the body approved the draft action minutes from the December 10, 2021 meeting, as well as the notes from the joint meeting with the Multimodal Transportation Commission held on December 16, 2021. Second, the commission adopted its annual report as presented. Third, the commission voted to reestablish the Public Space Management Committee, naming Andrew Fletcher, Steven Lee Johnson, Megan Rogers, and Guillaume Rodriguez as initial members, with the understanding that other members would be added later. No votes were taken on the two development projects reviewed during the meeting; instead, the commission provided feedback to staff to be forwarded to the Design Review Committee.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the review of the Starr Building Rehabilitation project at 28 Lexington Avenue and 72 Broadway, which proposes 4,500 square feet of retail space and a 35-room hotel. Andrew Fletcher expressed concern that the project was submitted just before City Council adopted a new ordinance requiring on-site parking for lodging, stating, "I think it defeats the intention of the city... I think we did the right thing in November requiring lodging to have on-site parking." Guillaume Rodriguez voiced dismay at the hotel use, noting, "I'm very dismayed that this is being stuck in the middle of one of the most beautiful buildings, I think, in the downtown." Kimberly Hunter asked if a special tax exists for off-site parking to cover road wear; staff clarified that no additional tax currently exists, though the area is a designated improvement district where a business improvement tax could potentially be adopted in the future.
The commission also reviewed a request by the McKibbin Hotel Group to add two one-story, louvered pergolas for outdoor dining in front of the Aris Hotel on Broadway. The discussion was largely critical of the design. Andrew Fletcher criticized the aesthetic, stating, "I think it's ugly as sin... I just I kind of don't exactly trust the applicant terribly much because we've had some interesting public space issues out of this applicant in the past." He described the structure as a "little tykes hood ornament on a Ferrari." Sage Turner added, "I'm also not a fan... It feels separated. I don't want to say that it is ugly, but aesthetically, I don't think it goes well with the building itself." Ricardo Seijo described the structure as looking like a "temporary structure that a nicer temporary structure they're putting out for the pandemic" and called it a "huge waste of an opportunity." Kimberly Hunter raised safety and ADA compliance concerns, stating, "it actually looks very dangerous to me." Chair Brian Moffitt recommended that if the structure is approved, it should be clearly defined as temporary and removable, or integrated into the building, rather than being a "rinky dink pretend thing."
Regarding the annual report and policy recommendations, Andrew Fletcher suggested budget allocation for a downtown master plan update and programming to create entrepreneurial opportunities for people not currently frequenting downtown. Kimberly Hunter urged the commission to be "micro hyper-focused" on using ARPA funds for multimodal and public space improvements to benefit those most impacted by the pandemic, rather than spreading resources too thin. Sage Turner noted that ARPA applications are already submitted, with presentations scheduled for February 1 and 2, and suggested the commission watch those presentations to inform their recommendations.
Follow-ups Several staff members and members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Staff member Will Tomquist, a Planner, agreed to note in the report for the Starr Building that the commission raised concerns about maintaining ingress/egress to Tingle Alley for residents during construction. Staff member Shannon, from Planning/Urban Design, agreed to send revised plans for 123 Haywood Street and 363 Hilliard Street to the commission via email so they can forward comments to the Design Review Committee. Sage Turner, serving as Council Liaison, agreed to send a summary of the day’s discussions regarding the hotel parking loophole and the Aris pergola to City Council to ensure they are aware of the commission’s concerns. Assistant City Manager Dana agreed to work with the Chair to finalize the language of the annual report’s policy recommendations before sending it to Council. Additionally, Dana agreed to look for the language of the "pedestrian first" resolution discussed at the previous joint meeting to see if it can be incorporated into the Public Space Management Committee’s work. Andrew Fletcher agreed to "pick up that ball and run with it" regarding the pedestrian-first policy, working with the newly formed task force to develop a recommendation.
Impact These decisions and discussions highlight the commission’s active role in shaping the physical and economic character of downtown Asheville. The reestablishment of the Public Space Management Committee signals a renewed focus on how public areas are utilized and maintained. The detailed feedback provided on the Starr Building and Aris Hotel projects will influence the Design Review Committee’s upcoming evaluations, potentially affecting how new developments interact with historic architecture and public safety. Furthermore, the commission’s push for focused ARPA funding and master plan updates aims to address long-term infrastructure and equity concerns in the downtown district.
Meeting Video & Transcript