Skip to main content
  • 1 h 28 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: December 10, 2021

The Asheville Downtown Commission met virtually on December 10, 2021, to review development impacts for two proposed projects, discuss commissioner recruitment, and receive updates from partner organizations. The only formal decision made at this meeting was the unanimous approval of the draft action minutes from the November 12, 2021 meeting. No formal votes were taken on the project reviews discussed, as these items were presented for development impact analysis and recommendations to be passed to the Planning Zoning Commission and Design Review Committee.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the review of a mixed-use development proposal at 363 Hilliard Avenue, which includes a five-story building with 160 residential units and 15,000 square feet of ground-level commercial space, alongside a three-story building with 36 residential units. Staff noted that while the project meets most Urban Design Ordinance requirements, it falls short on ground-level fenestration percentages. Commissioners raised concerns about the design’s "suburban" appearance, specifically citing the fiber cement siding and the monotony of the long Clingman Avenue facade. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson expressed frustration with the lack of creativity, stating, "My personal opinion is that the building, the streetscape, is lacking any sense of place whatsoever... This whole building and streetscape routine could be the same thing that you would see designed in St. Louis, Missouri or Mobile, Alabama... I'm just tired of it [minimum compliance]." Commissioner Andrew Fletcher also voiced concern over the increase in impervious surface from 63% to 87% and the prioritization of car storage. Additionally, Commissioner Ruth Summers questioned the long-term viability of the retail space given the rise of remote work.

The commission also reviewed a revised proposal for 123 Haywood Street, a four-story building originally designed as condominiums but now converted to a small hotel with ground-level retail. Staff clarified that the change in use impacts traffic and infrastructure needs and that the project is treated as a new application for design review purposes. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher expressed concern that the conversion of luxury condos to a hotel indicates a broader economic trend that could exacerbate the housing crunch, noting, "When even luxury housing is going to fold in the face of an opportunity to become hotels... that should scare people of a lot more income brackets than just mine." Commissioner Robin Raines commented on the design evolution, stating, "I do think it looked better before... Sometimes I think our ordinances don't necessarily make better buildings," referring to the removal of a previous courtyard feature.

In other business, staff shared results from a survey regarding desired skills for new commissioners, with top needs including representation of underrepresented perspectives and economic development knowledge. The application deadline for new commissioners is December 20, 2021, with City Council appointments scheduled for January 11, 2022. The Asheville Downtown Association reported on a successful parade and a new project to demonstrate the value of downtown through data and video, to be launched in early 2022. The meeting concluded with formal farewells to outgoing Commissioners Franzi Charan and Dane Barrager, with the Chair highlighting their contributions to local business advocacy and community engagement.

Regarding follow-up actions, staff agreed to verify with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) whether the request to relocate street trees on Clingman Avenue is a requirement or a preference for the 363 Hilliard project. Staff also agreed to share the commission’s comments on streetscape, stormwater, and "sense of place" with the Planning Zoning Commission and City Council as the project moves through the conditional zoning process. For the 123 Haywood Street project, staff agreed to communicate the commission’s comments regarding the loss of the courtyard, facade brightness, and sustainability to the Design Review Committee and the applicant. Additionally, staff agreed to work with the Chair and Vice Chair to schedule a special meeting or adjust the January meeting to accommodate the annual report, survey results, and new commissioner onboarding.

This meeting highlights ongoing tensions between development density and the preservation of Asheville’s unique character, particularly regarding streetscape design and the conversion of residential units to hotel uses. The discussions underscore the commission's role in providing detailed feedback to higher-level planning bodies, ensuring that development proposals align with the city's goals for a livable downtown and sustainable infrastructure.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches