Planning & Zoning Commission
December 1, 2021 at 4:59 PM
- 2 h 25 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On December 1, 2021, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a meeting to review zoning requests, ordinance amendments, and administrative items. The Commission approved the minutes from its previous meeting on November 3, 2021, and took action on three primary agenda items: a multifamily housing development, a dental office rezoning, and an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). Additionally, two items were postponed to the next meeting scheduled for January 5, 2022: a request to rezone two city-owned parcels at 285 Livingston Street and 415 South French Broad Avenue, and a zoning text amendment to Chapter 7 of the UDO regarding open space requirements.
Key Decisions
The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve the minutes from the November 3, 2021 meeting. Regarding the request to rezone a 22-acre parcel at 235 Sardis Road from Commercial Industrial to Residential Expansion Conditional Zone for a 297-unit multifamily apartment community, the Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve the conditional zoning request. This approval included an amendment to the future land use map from Industrial Manufacturing to Residential Neighborhood and a condition that the affordable housing units accept Section 8 Housing Choice Vouchers.
For the request to rezone a portion of a 1.5-acre parcel at 990 Tunnel Road from Residential Multifamily Low Density to Office 2 Conditional Zone for a two-story dental office, the Commission voted 6-1 to approve the conditional zoning request. The approval included a corresponding amendment to the Future Land Use Map from Residential Neighborhood to Traditional Corridor. Commissioner Faircloth was the sole dissenting vote, stating, "Unfortunately, I'm going to vote nay on this one. I just wish the best for the applicants, and I appreciate their willingness to grow the business. I just don't feel comfortable at this level."
Finally, the Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to approve proposed wording amendments to Chapter 7 of the UDO. These amendments update the membership structure of the Design Review Committee established by the Hotel Ordinance, reducing the number of seats appointed by the Downtown and Riverfront Commissions from four to three each, with the remaining three seats appointed at large by City Council.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the 235 Sardis Road project, staff and the applicant’s representative agreed to work offline to draft a condition regarding stream bank stabilization and restoration. The applicant’s engineer noted that they are working with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) to satisfy traffic recommendations, including signal timing changes. The project includes six four-story buildings, 437 parking spaces, and preserves daylighted streams with 30-foot buffers.
For the 990 Tunnel Road dental office, discussion focused on infrastructure, specifically the existing non-compliant 5-foot sidewalk on Tunnel Road and the feasibility of building a new sidewalk on Maple Springs Road versus Campground Road. The applicant stated they have reached out to Buncombe County Schools regarding the Maple Springs Road sidewalk and hopes to be on the January school board agenda. If that is not possible, the applicant agreed to pay a fee in lieu for the Campground Road sidewalk and dedicate an easement. Staff suggested the applicant pay a prorated fee in lieu for the 1-foot difference to bring the existing Tunnel Road sidewalk up to the 6-foot standard.
Regarding the Design Review Committee amendments, staff explained that the change aims to reduce the burden on the Downtown and Riverfront Commissions to find members willing to serve in both capacities. Staff noted, "We think that this will help reduce the burden on those commissions to find members that are interested in serving in both capacities. Because right now you have to find four people from the Riverfront Commission and four people from the Downtown Commission who are willing to serve on the Design Review Committee, which effectively operates as a whole separate commission."
Follow-ups
Staff and the applicant’s representative for 235 Sardis Road agreed to work offline to draft a condition regarding stream bank stabilization and restoration. For 990 Tunnel Road, the applicant agreed to pay a fee in lieu for the Campground Road sidewalk and dedicate an easement if the Maple Springs Road sidewalk is not approved by the school board. Staff suggested the applicant pay a prorated fee in lieu for the 1-foot difference in the Tunnel Road sidewalk width. Additionally, staff and the Chair discussed revising the condition regarding facade articulation to be more specific. Staff stated that the proposed amendments to Chapter 7 of the UDO, along with previously reviewed hotel development standards, will go to City Council, with the Design Review Committee structure amendment scheduled for December 14.
Impact
These decisions impact the development landscape in Asheville by approving a significant multifamily housing project that includes affordable units and a new dental office near Bell Elementary School. The approval of the UDO Chapter 7 amendment streamlines the appointment process for the Design Review Committee, potentially making it easier for the Downtown and Riverfront Commissions to fulfill their roles. The postponement of the open space requirements amendment and the city-owned parcel rezoning indicates that these topics will require further review in the new year.
Meeting Video & Transcript