Skip to main content

Planning & Zoning Commission

November 3, 2021 at 5:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Oct 6 meetingNext: Dec 1 meeting
  • 1 h 7 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a meeting on November 3, 2021, to address three primary agenda items. Two other items—a legislative public hearing for rezoning city-owned parcels and a zoning text amendment regarding open space requirements—were postponed to the December 1, 2021 meeting. The commission reviewed a new hotel site plan, a zoning map amendment for a recently purchased property, and amendments to the city’s hotel development standards.

Key Decisions

The commission approved the meeting minutes unanimously. Regarding the site plan for a new hotel at 50 Collier Avenue, the commission voted 6-1 to recommend approval of the project, subject to outstanding technical and design review conditions. The vote included ayes from Commissioners Levi, Hoke, Barton, Simmons, Faircloth, and Chair Archibald, with Commissioner Bubenik voting nay. For the zoning map amendment concerning 2351 Sweet’n Creek Road, the commission unanimously approved the initial request to rezone the property to RS2 (Residential Single-Family Low Density) and assign a future land use designation of "Parks and Open Space." Finally, the commission unanimously approved proposed wording amendments to Chapter 7 of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding hotel development standards.

Discussion Highlights

During the review of the 50 Collier Avenue hotel, staff confirmed the project met technical standards, including street activation and landscape compliance. A commissioner raised concerns about the requirement to tear out and replace a relatively new 5-foot sidewalk with a new 10-foot sidewalk, citing sustainability and cost. Staff explained that because the project involves full boundary-to-boundary reconstruction, a "two-pour" alternative to keep the old sidewalk was technically difficult for Public Works to accept without a demonstrated unique hardship.

For the 2351 Sweet’n Creek Road property, which the City purchased from Carolina Day School for park expansion, staff initially proposed a "Residential Neighborhood" future land use designation. Commissioners questioned this, noting the property is intended for park facilities. Commissioner Geoffrey Barton stated, "I think Sweeton Creek is too overloaded for any more neighborhoods as it currently stands. So if there is any way to make this the parks land use zoning, I'd be much more comfortable with that personally." Commissioner Jenifer Bubenik added, "I just also want to support Commissioner Faircloth in that it needs to be parks and open space. Doesn't need to be any more residential neighborhood off of Sweet and Creek Road." Consequently, the designation was amended to "Parks and Open Space."

The discussion on Chapter 7 hotel standards focused on clarifying definitions to prevent short-term vacation rentals from being classified as hotels. Staff Member Shannon Tuck explained, "So with Asheville's housing situation as it is, there's been a desire to discourage those kind of small homes projects that could be housing rather than hotels. If you want to do an actual boutique hotel, we still have the flexibility to do that. But if you're going to do the full facilities that provide sanitation, sleeping and cooking accommodations, then that needs to be a dwelling unit, unless you are a truly extended stay hotel." The amendments define Extended Stay Hotels as a subset of Large Hotels requiring dedicated lobbies and in-house housekeeping, and Small Hotels as having 7–35 rooms.

Follow-ups

Staff explained that the next step for the Sweet’n Creek Road property is for City Council to vote on a resolution to set the public hearing for voluntary annexation at their next meeting. The zoning designation will be assigned on the same night as the annexation hearing in December. Additionally, staff will review the design for the projecting canopies on Collier Avenue during the final technical review of the 50 Collier Avenue hotel.

Impact

These decisions impact the development landscape in Asheville by establishing clearer regulations for hotel construction and defining the use of newly acquired city land. The approval of the 50 Collier Avenue site plan allows for the construction of a 62,000-square-foot building with 25 hotel rooms, 7 extended-stay units, and 3 condominium units, provided the applicant meets conditions such as adding projecting canopies to pedestrian entrances. The rezoning of the Sweet’n Creek Road property to RS2 with a "Parks and Open Space" future land use designation aligns the legal zoning with the city's intent to expand park facilities rather than add residential density to that area. The Chapter 7 amendments update the UDO following a 17-month moratorium on hotel development, aiming to distinguish true hotels from short-term rentals and clarify parking and storefront requirements in the Central Business District and River Arts District.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches