Skip to main content
  • 1 h 50 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a meeting on November 18, 2021, to review several development projects and discuss internal policy changes. The agenda included formal and informal design reviews for three specific properties, a proposal to alter the committee’s appointment process, and the approval of previous minutes.

Key Decisions

The committee took several unanimous actions during the session. First, the motion to approve the minutes from the October 21, 2021 meeting passed with all members voting aye. Second, regarding the project at 123 Haywood Street, the committee unanimously voted to continue the formal design review to the December meeting while proceeding with an informal review immediately. Third, the committee unanimously voted to forward the project at 324 Biltmore Avenue to City Council with specific recommendations. Finally, the committee unanimously voted to move a proposed ordinance change regarding the committee’s appointment process forward to City Council. The meeting concluded with a unanimous motion to adjourn.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the formal design review for 324 Biltmore Avenue, a hotel project seeking a conditional zoning amendment. The discussion centered on facade changes, specifically the use of Engineered Fiber Insulation Sheathing (EFIS), blank walls, and greenery. Chair Jane Matthews expressed concern about the pedestrian experience, stating, "I find it very important as architecture. It's just not very friendly." She also criticized the use of EFIS, noting, "I really cannot [support] EFIS... it's just not a permanent material and really does nothing to elevate architecture in our city." Member Brian Moffitt commented that he "still don't think they've addressed the blank wall" and expressed frustration with the reliance on murals over architectural detail. Member Steven Lee Johnson advised the applicant that, given the south-facing orientation, he would "strongly encourage no fake plants," warning that the town would "pick you apart fast" on such details. Staff member Shannon Tuck clarified that while the project is a conditional zoning amendment and not subject to the mandatory positive recommendation required for Level 2 hotels, the committee was providing recommendations to Council.

The committee also conducted an informal review of 72 Broadway, a mixed-use project involving a hotel and residential units. The discussion focused on massing, articulation, and the building’s relationship to the downtown context. Member Jeremy Goldstein asked for clarification on the definition of "articulation," leading to a discussion where staff and members explained it as creating clear distinctions between building parts through materials, shadow lines, or massing. Member Brian Moffitt emphasized the need for better articulation, noting, "That corner looks unarticulated and unexpressed for such a prominent piece."

Additionally, the committee reviewed a proposed change to its own appointment process, which would shift from a mix of commission-appointed and self-appointed seats to all nine seats being appointed by City Council. The committee also conducted a second informal look at 123 Haywood Street, focusing on the design implications of changing the use from residential to a small hotel. During this review, the applicant defended the use of white metal panels by comparing them to "Moose's Tooth" in Alaska, aiming to "visually minimize its impact on the landscape." Chair Matthews responded, "This isn't Alaska, and I really don't see that as relevant to downtown."

Follow-ups

Staff member Shannon Tuck stated she would provide sample language for a condition regarding the mural on the 324 Biltmore Avenue project, specifying that it be produced by a local artist and be non-branded. No other members or staff members explicitly agreed to follow-up actions at this meeting.

Impact

These decisions impact the development landscape in Asheville’s downtown area. The recommendations for 324 Biltmore Avenue will be considered by City Council, potentially influencing the final facade design of the hotel. The proposal to change the committee’s appointment process to be fully appointed by City Council, if adopted, would alter how the Design Review Committee is staffed. The deferral of the formal review for 123 Haywood Street to December indicates that the project’s final design approval is pending further review.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches