Design Review Committee
October 21, 2021 at 12:30 PM
- 1 h 40 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on October 21, 2021, to review four development projects. The committee addressed one formal design review, one level one project, and two informal design reviews. The agenda included discussions on building massing, material selections, pedestrian access, and site amenities for mixed-use and hotel developments.
Key Decisions
The committee began by approving the minutes from the September 16, 2021 meeting by unanimous vote. Regarding the project at 488 South Market Street, the committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the December 16, 2021 meeting due to issues with the design submittal.
For the formal design review of 50 Collier Avenue, a mixed-use project featuring a hotel, condominiums, and retail space, the committee voted unanimously to recommend approval subject to three specific conditions. First, the bike rack design and location must be moved from the intersection corner to a point accessible to the public, consistent with building detailing and City standards. Second, pedestrian entrances for the hotel and condos must be addressed with a design consistent with the building’s detailing, including a canopy or projecting element that reflects the balcony and front metal design elements. Third, rooftop structures must be revised to be consistent with the main design and metal elements. No votes were taken on the informal reviews for 363 Hilliard Avenue and 324 Biltmore Avenue. The meeting was adjourned by unanimous vote.
Discussion Highlights
During the review of 50 Collier Avenue, the discussion focused on the building’s massing, the use of metal and brick materials, and the treatment of pedestrian entrances. Staff member Shannon requested that the committee provide as much detail as possible in the approval conditions to help staff determine compliance, noting that vague conditions create dilemmas for staff. Applicant Peter Alvarez explained that a round element on the roof was intended to symbolize a large brewing vessel, a nod to the brewing process.
For the informal review of 363 Hilliard Avenue, a large mixed-use development, the committee debated the building’s large mass and material choices. Chair Jane Matthews expressed a strong preference against fiber cement siding, stating, "I'm not a big fan of fiber cement siding at all. I just don't think... it's not an urban material." She added, "I'm particularly disturbed about the board and batten use of it. I mean, to me, that is not urban at all." Member Brian Moffitt concurred, stating, "I want to concur with Jane that I would prefer this to be an urban building with urban materials and urban detailing than a suburban apartment building in terms of its materials and detailing." Moffitt also suggested that introducing glass elements might help break the building up into separate structures. When discussing material costs for affordable housing, Moffitt stated, "I want all of our people to have good materials, even the ones in affordable housing."
In the informal review of 324 Biltmore Avenue, a hotel project, the committee discussed the building’s "prototypical" appearance, brand colors, and facade materials. Member Robin Raines commented, "I think this is an improvement over the first design. I like it better." The discussion also addressed the visibility of the parking structure from public ways and the use of EIFS (Exterior Insulation and Finish System) as a facade material.
Community Input
There were no public comments recorded for any of the agenda items. The chair confirmed that there was no one in the phone queue for public comment during the 50 Collier Avenue review and again before adjourning the meeting.
Follow-ups
Staff member Sasha noted that staff will review the canopy design and bike rack location for 50 Collier Avenue to ensure compliance with the committee’s conditions. For 363 Hilliard Avenue, staff member Sasha noted that the applicant will return for a formal review after incorporating the committee's notes on massing and materials. For 324 Biltmore Avenue, staff member Shannon noted that the applicant will need to return for a formal review and will eventually need to go before City Council to amend their conditional zoning.
Impact
These decisions impact the aesthetic and functional development of the city’s commercial corridors. The approval of 50 Collier Avenue with specific conditions ensures that the new mixed-use development integrates with its surroundings through consistent detailing and accessible public amenities. The feedback provided on 363 Hilliard Avenue and 324 Biltmore Avenue emphasizes the committee’s focus on using urban-appropriate materials and breaking up large building masses to prevent a monolithic appearance, which will guide the applicants' future design revisions before formal approval.
Meeting Video & Transcript