Urban Forestry Commission
November 2, 2021 at 1:00 PM
- 3 h 14 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On November 2, 2021, the City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened to address a range of urban forestry and stormwater issues. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, public comment on the Vermont Avenue sidewalk project, a presentation by the Stormwater Task Force, an update on the Vermont Avenue Capital Projects, staff reports, and a detailed review of the proposed Open Space Amendment.
Key Decisions
The Commission approved the minutes from the October meeting via a roll call vote in which all present members voted "Aye." The most significant decision of the evening concerned the proposed Open Space Amendment. A motion was made to oppose the amendment and urge the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council to reject it. This motion failed with a tally of 3 Ayes and 5 Nays. Consequently, the Commission did not adopt a formal position opposing the amendment at this meeting. The chair noted that the group needs to clarify its position, and members suggested taking time to regroup and consider an alternate motion before the item proceeds to the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council.
Discussion Highlights
A major portion of the meeting focused on the Vermont Avenue bond-funded sidewalk replacement project. Capital Projects presented the plan, which includes the removal of trees, prompting significant debate. The Commission expressed concern over the lack of information regarding tree health and the plan to remove all maples on the northern part of the street. Chair Amy Smith stated that the Commission would appreciate the opportunity to be at the table to provide help and expertise. Commissioner Perrin highlighted that the Commission’s key priorities for changes in the Open Space Amendment, established in August 2020, were all rejected in the current proposal. He noted that the amendment allows for a reduction of required open space from 50% of a parcel to 5%, describing the cuts as "pretty dramatic." Commissioner Cecil Bothwell criticized the amendment as a "total giveaway to developers," while Commissioner Patrick argued that the amendment would not drastically reduce the urban tree canopy and that other objectives were more critical to preservation.
The Stormwater Task Force presented recommendations regarding the stormwater ordinance, green infrastructure, and budget/fee studies. No formal vote was taken on these recommendations. Additionally, City Arborist Mark Foster reported that he is currently 70% staffed, noting he has not had that level of staffing in over a year. Staff also discussed the legal risks associated with the Fee-in-Lieu program, noting that regardless of proximity, the city faces similar lawsuit risks without a clear cost-benefit analysis.
Community Input
During the public comment period, residents and members of the Tree Protection Task Force (TPFT) raised concerns about the Vermont Avenue project. A resident asked if rubber sidewalks had been considered to protect trees on Veronica Avenue. Another resident expressed concern about the removal of 90+ year-old trees on Vermont Avenue, asking the Commission to research how other progressive cities handle tree canopy preservation and suggesting sidewalks be moved to the street side. Members did not respond directly to these written comments during the public comment period.
In live comments, a TPFT member expressed concern that the plan to remove maples was moving ahead without adequate consultation with the neighborhood or the Commission, urging the Commission to slow the process to allow for a wider assessment of tree health. The Chair stated that the issue would be discussed later in the meeting. Another TPFT member echoed these concerns, stating the process felt "steamrolled ahead" by certain staff, and suggested permeable pavement as an ADA-compliant alternative. The Chair acknowledged the speakers but did not provide a specific reply. A third written comment from a Vermont Avenue resident asked the city to do its best to save every tree on the street, noting that innovative alternatives exist. The Chair thanked the commenter and transitioned to the Vermont Avenue presentation.
Follow-ups
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:
- Stormwater Task Force: The Task Force representative agreed to send updates to the Chair to be brought to the group for the December meeting.
- Vermont Avenue Working Group: The Chair and the Capital Projects Project Manager agreed to get in touch to hold a canopy discussion with a small working group from the Commission.
- Open Space Amendment: Members agreed to regroup and determine what is necessary for a motion to address the Commission's opinion on the amendment.
- Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance: Staff member Chris Collins agreed to put together a GIS map with data requested by the Commission to help with decision-making for the Fee-in-Lieu program.
- Chapter 20 Working Group: Two members agreed to get together in the next week or so to work out next steps for the Chapter 20 policy working group.
- Budget Working Group: The group is working on a presentation to give to City Council, hopefully in December.
- Collaboration with SACIE: The Chair agreed to attend a SACIE subcommittee meeting to give an overview of budget requests and encourage support for the urban forester and master plan.
- Website Correction: The Chair agreed to ensure the website is updated to reflect that the Commission has a December meeting.
- Annual Get-Together: The Chair will send out date options for an informal in-person lunch/get-together for the end of the year.
- Membership: The Chair and another member will review applications for the open commission seat.
- Annual Report: The Chair will put together the annual report, seeking input from members via email.
Impact
This meeting highlights the ongoing tension between infrastructure development and urban canopy preservation in Asheville. The failure of the motion to oppose the Open Space Amendment means the Commission has not yet established a unified stance against the proposed zoning changes, which critics argue could significantly reduce required open space on new developments. The intense scrutiny of the Vermont Avenue project underscores the community's demand for greater consultation and alternative solutions, such as permeable pavement, to protect mature trees during sidewalk replacements. As the Commission moves toward its December meeting, residents should note that the Open Space Amendment is currently penciled in for a City Council agenda on December 14, though the Commission is still working to define its final position on the issue.
Meeting Video & Transcript