Skip to main content
  • 1 h 5 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Board of Adjustment Meeting Recap: October 25, 2021

The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment met on October 25, 2021, to address two variance requests related to steep slope development standards under the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). The meeting focused on specific land disturbance and setback issues for properties located on steep terrain.

Key Decisions The Board granted both variances presented at the meeting. For Case 1, involving 124 Macaulay Drive, a motion was made by Paul Wilczynski and seconded by Bill Newman to grant a variance reducing the front setback from 20 feet to 0–1 feet. The vote was 4 ayes and 0 nays, resulting in a unanimous approval. For Case 2, involving 258 Vance Gap Road, a motion was made by the Chair and seconded by Suzanne Vernon Godsey to grant a variance allowing an additional 6,200 square feet of land disturbance. This motion also passed with 4 ayes and 0 nays, granting the variance unanimously. The approval of the July and September meeting minutes was postponed because the documents were not prepared or received in time for the meeting.

Discussion Highlights Staff and design professionals presented exhibits for the Macaulay Drive case, noting that the requested variance would result in approximately 7,288 square feet of land disturbance, whereas adhering to the standard 20-foot setback would require 9,005 square feet of disturbance and a driveway grade of 24%, which exceeds recommended limits. For the Vance Gap Road case, staff presented zoning maps and historical aerials showing that existing driveways and a fire truck turnaround, which pre-date the 2007 steep slope ordinance, had already consumed approximately 9,978 square feet of the allowed grading area.

Assistant Attorney Eric Edgerton noted that the situation was unique, as the grading section of the steep slope ordinance did not contemplate a lot where so much area is taken up by non-house grading. He clarified that the Board is allowed to consider the application of restrictive covenants, such as the Homeowners Association requirement for a minimum house size of 2,500 square feet, in their decision. Chair Prateek Bhakta stated that an owner should not be penalized for things that occurred prior to ordinance changes, suggesting it would be a penalty not to approve the variance. Member Bill Newman asked why existing infrastructure was not grandfathered through if it was platted prior to the steep slope development. Staff Ricky Hurley explained that while the parcel’s average natural slope allows for 25% disturbance, the existing infrastructure had used up nearly all of that allowance.

Community Input During public comment for the Vance Gap Road case, a prospective buyer of the lot spoke via a direct cell phone relay due to audio difficulties with the conference bridge. The commenter stated that she and her husband were interested in purchasing the lot only if the variance was approved, noting that the HOA minimum house size prevented them from building a smaller home within the current ordinance limits. She expressed a desire to minimize land disruption by potentially using a daylight or weekend basement design. No board members responded directly to the content of the public comment; the Chair administered the oath to the caller and then closed public comment. No public comments were recorded for the Macaulay Drive case, as two callers on the line did not press the button to speak.

Follow-ups Staff member Ricky Hurley stated that the July minutes were not yet prepared and he hoped to have them done by November. He noted that the September minutes were received late on Friday and were too lengthy to review that day. Regarding the Macaulay Drive case, staff noted that the applicants had reached out to the Transportation department regarding a potential right-of-way reduction, but no response had been received. No further action was directed by the board on this matter.

Impact These decisions allow the property owners to proceed with construction plans that deviate from standard steep slope regulations. For the Macaulay Drive property, the variance minimizes grading and maintains a similar building relationship to the street as neighboring lots. For the Vance Gap Road property, the variance permits the construction of a home that meets HOA size requirements, which would otherwise be impossible within the remaining ordinance allowance due to pre-existing infrastructure.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches