Board of Adjustment
September 27, 2021 at 2:00 PM
- 1 h 41 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment met on September 27, 2021, to review the minutes from the August 2021 meeting and hear two variance requests. The board ratified the August 2021 minutes, noting that the July 2021 minutes were still pending and would be addressed once finalized. The meeting focused on two land use cases: a request for an aquatic buffer variance for a multifamily development at 9999 Hazel Mill Road and a request for a rear setback variance for a residential addition at 23 Cloverly Way.
The board first addressed the request from Mike LaVoy, representing the owner of 9999 Hazel Mill Road, LLC, for a variance to remove the 30-foot aquatic buffer requirement for a wetland on the property. The petitioner sought to allow for the construction of a 23-unit multifamily development. During the discussion, LaVoy explained that beavers and fallen trees had contributed to the wetland's growth, stating that without the variance, 37% of the property would be unusable. He emphasized the project's commitment to low-impact development. Charlie Pond, a representative for the development team, noted that the wetland had grown from under 0.1 acres to over 0.1 acres, triggering the variance requirement under current regulations. Pond also stated the goal was to create for-sale housing affordable to the workforce population. Attorney Craig Justice argued that the zoning district was intended for infill, higher-density housing rather than single-family detached uses, and respectfully asked the board to grant the variance due to the hardships associated with the buffer. Suzanne Vernon Godsey, a board member, noted that the Army Corps of Engineers had determined the wetland to be low-grade and growing due to environmental impacts outside of anyone's control. Staff member Nancy Watford clarified that staff does not typically make recommendations for or against variances, presenting only facts regarding the wetland’s quality and jurisdictionality. The board voted to grant the variance, with all voting members voting "Yes."
The second item was a request from Diane Weaver for a variance to the rear setback standards for the RS4 zoning district at 23 Cloverly Way. Weaver sought to reduce the required 25-foot rear setback to 13 feet to allow for a sunroom addition to her home, which backs up to the Blue Ridge Parkway. She explained that the rear of the property had suffered from mold issues due to lack of visibility and ventilation, and the addition was intended to allow more sunlight to prevent future problems. Weaver stated that her neighbors were fully enthusiastic about the project. The Chair noted that one caller was on the line for public comment but did not press the button to speak, so no public comments were recorded for this case. The board voted to grant the variance, with a recorded vote of 5-0 in favor.
Regarding community input, one public commenter asked the petitioner for the Hazel Mill Road project to clarify the location of the proposed building and parking on the property map. The petitioner explained that the building would be terraced into the steep slope, with parking at the upper elevation and a boardwalk connecting to the sidewalk along Craven Street. No board members responded to this specific clarification request. For the Cloverly Way case, no public comments were recorded as the caller did not speak.
No explicit follow-ups were agreed to by board members or staff during the meeting. However, the petitioner for the Hazel Mill Road project stated that the property line had not been replatted after the Craven Street reconfiguration and that they intended to work with the City to replat the right-of-way area, describing this as a separate issue from the variance request.
These decisions allow for the construction of a 23-unit multifamily development on a steep, wetland-adjacent lot and a small residential addition on a property backing to the Blue Ridge Parkway. The grants of these variances permit development and construction that would otherwise be prohibited by the Unified Development Ordinance’s buffer and setback standards.
Meeting Video & Transcript