Skip to main content
  • 1 h 21 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Downtown Commission held a meeting on October 8, 2021. The primary agenda items included the approval of previous minutes, development impact discussions for two specific projects, and updates regarding the new noise ordinance, American Rescue Plan (ARPA) funding, and local paving projects.

Key Decisions

The Commission’s only formal vote was to approve the minutes from the September 10, 2021 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and a roll call vote resulted in a unanimous approval. The meeting concluded when the Chair moved to adjourn; no formal vote was recorded, and the meeting ended as members indicated their agreement to leave.

Discussion Highlights

The Commission spent a significant portion of the meeting discussing the development impact of two projects. For the Level 1 project at 48 South Market Street, a historic restoration adding one floor with two rental apartments and commercial space, discussion focused on the building’s proximity to property lines and the inclusion of murals. A member suggested the murals reflect the area’s history, specifically referencing African American small business ownership on Eagle Market Street and the historical presence of pear trees. The project owner, Dane Berger, stated that the first floor will be commercial space and that they are hoping to attract a Black-owned business, acknowledging past difficulties in doing so.

For the Level 2 project at 50 Collier Avenue, a three-story building containing a 25-room hotel, extended-stay units, three condominiums, and ground-floor retail, the debate centered on the design’s impact on the streetscape. Member Kimberly Hunter expressed that the design feels "walled off" and does not interact well with the street, noting that the building’s proportions and materials have changed significantly since the first review. Member Robin Raines criticized the design as "arbitrary" and "cold," stating that while the architect intended a warehouse look, it was not successful and lacked detailing. Member Sage Turner raised concerns about the lack of lighting on the sidewalks, noting that as a woman, she would not feel safe walking down that street at night.

The Commission also discussed the recent separation of the Downtown Commission and Design Review Committee processes. Member Kimberly Hunter stated that bifurcating design review from broader community concerns creates a process that isolates projects, allowing gentrification and displacement to continue as a "slow burn" because the review focuses only on building codes rather than people. A staff member, Shannon, explained that for "by-right" projects like the one at 50 Collier, the Commission does not have the authority to consider non-technical standards like the balance of uses, but that their comments are still heard by the applicant.

Regarding the new noise ordinance, which went into effect last month, Member Kimberly Hunter warned that such ordinances historically skew toward marginalizing people with fewer socioeconomic means, who may work late or live in multi-unit housing. She requested that the evaluation data include measures of marginalization to ensure the ordinance does not disproportionately affect lower-income residents.

Follow-ups

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting:

  • Staff member Shannon agreed to circulate draft language for the "extended stay" definition to Commission members and proposed holding short, informal 15-minute meetings with interested members to explain the nuances before the item goes to Planning and Zoning in November.
  • Staff agreed to collect data on noise complaints, including demographic and socioeconomic markers, and share this information with the Commission before it is presented to City Council.
  • Staff member Sasha stated that the Commission’s design comments regarding the 50 Collier Avenue project, specifically regarding streetscape, lighting, and building organization, would be transferred to the Design Review Board for their meeting the following week.
  • The Chair agreed to place the question of whether to continue the Local Living Economy working group on the next agenda.
  • The Chair agreed to work on re-convening the public space management subcommittee, which had been inactive for about two years.
  • The Chair agreed to begin working on a summary of the Commission’s objectives and priorities for a year-in-review presentation to Council, likely before the December meeting.

Impact

These discussions highlight the Commission's role in balancing development with community well-being. The detailed critique of the 50 Collier Avenue project underscores ongoing concerns about how new construction affects pedestrian safety, street activation, and the overall character of the downtown area. The focus on the noise ordinance’s potential socioeconomic impact reflects an effort to ensure that public health and safety regulations do not inadvertently harm vulnerable populations. Additionally, the review of the 48 South Market Street project emphasizes the importance of preserving and celebrating the area's cultural history through design elements like murals and the support of local, Black-owned businesses.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches