Skip to main content
  • 2 h 5 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: September 10, 2021

The Downtown Commission of the City of Asheville convened on September 10, 2021, to review administrative records, receive public comment, and discuss various development projects and city initiatives. The agenda included the approval of previous meeting minutes, a presentation from the Office of Data and Performance (ODAP), reviews of three specific development projects, and updates from the Design Review Committee, the Asheville Downtown Association, and City Staff.

Key Decisions The only formal vote taken during the meeting was the unanimous approval of the draft action minutes from the August 13, 2021, meeting. The meeting was subsequently adjourned by motion. No formal votes were cast on the three development projects presented—39 Patton Avenue, 217 Hilliard Avenue, and 61 Biltmore Avenue—as these were discussed as informational "development impact discussions." Final approval authority for these projects rests with the Design Review Committee or City Council.

Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on data equity and governance. Natalie Bailey from ODAP presented on the office’s mission and engagement strategies. Eric Jackson of ODAP emphasized the need for deliberate questioning regarding data completeness, stating, "If you’re going to respond to the question... I don’t have an easy answer... It is a nice segue partly into the governance piece... It’s important that we... are very deliberate about asking questions about completeness."

Safety and design standards were also central to the discussion. Commissioner Hunter stressed the critical importance of lighting in design, stating, "Every time we leave lighting out of a design element, we’re actually continuing to perpetuate harms against our community members. It has to be a priority... I want to continue to emphasize it over and over again like a broken record until it gets fixed." Regarding the 61 Biltmore Avenue project (Moxie Hotel), Commissioner Fletcher expressed concern over the lack of balanced growth, noting, "I just absolutely do not see a balance of growth happening here... I’m not pleased to see that the potential for adding housing here has been surpassed for the potential of profit off of people who don’t live here." Additionally, Stacy Merton from Planning and Urban Design explained that staff are recommending an update to the definition of "hotel" to specifically exclude condo hotels, which would not meet the new operational criteria.

Community Input A written public comment highlighted the poor condition of downtown Patton Avenue, urging "major attention" to its upkeep as a reflection of the city. In response, commissioners clarified that the section west of Ashland Avenue is a state road, meaning the City does not control paving schedules there, though the downtown portion is city-maintained. Residents were advised to use the Asheville app to report potholes and road issues to build a case for repairs.

Follow-ups Several specific follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Natalie Bailey agreed to connect with a commissioner to identify contacts within the LGBTQ+ and Latino/Hispanic communities to ensure their inclusion in data collection and engagement efforts. A commissioner agreed to speak with the chair and vice chair to request that staff develop a guiding policy or best practices for street lighting. Staff are to ensure the 217 Hilliard project utilizes the latest tree planting standards, including silver cells and interconnected root zones, which are currently being finalized. Furthermore, a staff member agreed to consult with transportation staff regarding the timeline for relocating the transit shelter to prevent service gaps and to investigate the potential for adding a crosswalk or on-street parking at the alley entrance on Biltmore Avenue. Finally, the chair stated they would place an item on a future agenda to discuss parklets and winter plans in light of extended public health mandates.

Impact These discussions highlight the Commission’s focus on balancing development with community needs, particularly regarding housing versus commercial profit and the integration of safety features like lighting. The review of the three development projects provides transparency into upcoming changes in the downtown area, including a facade restoration, a micro-housing infill development, and a hotel expansion. The commitment to inclusive data collection and the development of lighting policies aim to address equity and safety concerns raised by both staff and commissioners.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches