Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
October 7, 2021 at 9:30 AM
- 1 h 54 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Meeting Recap: October 7, 2021
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) met on October 7, 2021, to review housing market trends, task force updates, and community development projects. The committee’s primary formal action was the approval of the minutes from its previous meeting on September 2, 2021. Beyond this procedural vote, the session focused on strategic discussions regarding affordable housing incentives, infrastructure barriers, and the allocation of federal and local funds.
Key Decisions The only formal vote taken during the meeting was to approve the minutes from the September 2, 2021 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the minutes were approved with all members in favor. No other motions or decisions were recorded.
Discussion Highlights The committee reviewed reports on the housing market, noting the "bleak" availability of low-cost housing. The Chair expressed shock at current price points, stating that the average house price in Asheville was "400 something thousand" and in Buncombe County was "500,000," describing the figures as "stunning." Staff clarified eligibility rules for the "Thrive" program, explaining that it is restricted to residents of specific project-based developments moving to tenant mobility vouchers who are families with children.
Task force updates highlighted significant infrastructure barriers. The Build Task Force reported that meetings with city departments, specifically the Metropolitan Sewer District (MSD), revealed that the MSD charter does not allow for extending sewer lines for new developments, relying instead on private developers, though exceptions exist for affordable housing projects. The Chair noted, "I found that was really interesting because... it’s not a state thing. It’s something specifically in MSD’s charter." The Connect Task Force outlined plans to conduct outreach to affordable housing partners to gauge public access and unit availability.
A roundtable discussion focused on creating "scaled" affordable housing rebates to incentivize developers who commit to affordability for periods shorter than the standard 20-year deed restriction. Members emphasized the need for flexibility for small developers, Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), and existing landlords. The Chair suggested tying incentives to a "cumulative approach," arguing that 100% of units at 30% Area Median Income (AMI) for five years might be as valuable as 20% of units for 20 years. Another member stated, "I think having a hard fast rule is... really discouraging to not only larger developers, but also certainly to smaller developers that the 20 year... it’s either all or nothing." Staff cautioned against requiring voucher acceptance, noting that such mandates "don’t work super successfully" because landlords may still choose non-voucher applicants if available.
Community development updates covered several active sites. Staff provided status reports on 319 Biltmore (developer selection of Homes Urban), Cedar Hill/Deeperview (ongoing discussions on a partner agreement), and Pineview (developer pivoting to a different site due to cost challenges, expected to return to the Housing and Community Development department in November). The Talbot Lot is currently in the transportation department’s purview for grant funding, with a Request for Proposals (RFP) for the housing portion anticipated. Staff presented a proposal to use Down Payment Assistance (DPA) funds in combination with land banking dollars to purchase and make a site pad-ready for approximately 40 affordable homes, potentially reinstituting a "dollar lot" program. Staff emphasized regarding this proposal: "No decisions made, no decisions made, no decisions made. Just... we are trying to find a... strategic and effective way." The committee also discussed the evaluation of American Rescue Plan (ARPA) funds and coordination with the County Affordable Housing Committee regarding 4% tax credit deals and the Deschutes Ferry Road parcel.
Community Input One public commenter submitted a written inquiry asking if meetings could be viewed in real-time via a web address. Staff reported that they had already contacted the individual via email to confirm that meetings are broadcast live on the city’s public input platform and YouTube, providing the necessary links. No further response was received from the commenter, and no other public comments were received during the open comment period.
Follow-Ups Several follow-up actions were agreed to by the Chair and staff:
- The Chair agreed to look at shuffling members or providing support to help solidify the Connect Task Force’s meeting schedule.
- The Chair agreed to send out the list of MSD committees provided by a staff member from the Water/MSD department to the committee members.
- The Chair agreed to research past agendas and lists of properties that received fee rebates under the old "first turn" model to research their current status and affordability.
- The Chair agreed to research ADU incentives and data from other states, specifically California, to bring to the next meeting.
- Staff agreed to add ARPA funding information to the next community development update.
- Staff agreed to add the Deschutes Ferry Road parcel to their check-in list regarding city-county partnerships.
- Staff confirmed that the committee will be asked to provide input on Housing Trust Fund and Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) applications coming to the Housing and Community Development department, including the Lanius/Center Grant project and potential returns from the Pineview developer.
- The potential use of DPA funds for land acquisition/pad-ready sites will be placed on the agenda for the next meeting for a complete policy discussion.
Impact This meeting addressed the critical gap between housing costs and affordability in Asheville and Buncombe County. By identifying specific barriers such as MSD sewer line restrictions and exploring flexible incentive structures for short-term affordability commitments, the committee is working to remove obstacles for small developers and existing landlords. The review of federal ARPA funds and the proposal to utilize DPA funds for land acquisition indicate a strategic shift toward leveraging public resources to create ready-to-build sites for affordable housing, a topic that will undergo full policy discussion at the next meeting.
Meeting Video & Transcript