Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
December 2, 2021 at 9:47 AM
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee held a virtual meeting on December 2, 2021. The session focused on reviewing monthly updates regarding housing projects, staffing changes within the Community Development department, and proposed policy adjustments related to equity and development pauses.
Key Decisions
The only formal action taken during the meeting was the approval of the minutes from the previous month. A motion to accept the minutes was made and seconded, and the chair called for a vote, which passed unanimously. No other formal votes or motions were recorded.
Discussion Highlights
Staff provided updates on high-impact housing sites, noting that the 360 Hilliard project is in its closeout phase while the 319 Biltmore project is in negotiation. The committee discussed the timeline for the $25 million affordable housing bond, which has a deadline of November 2023. Concerns were raised regarding whether the bond requires funds to be merely allocated or actually spent and constructed by that date. Additionally, the committee reviewed data on homes listed below $275,000, noting that most of these properties are "dozer bait" (where land value exceeds building value) or fixer-uppers, rather than habitable affordable housing.
Task force updates highlighted specific barriers to development. The Build Task Force discussed obstacles to infill development, including the Metropolitan Sewer District’s inability to extend its own utility lines and the Water Department’s limit of five simultaneous applications due to staffing constraints and paper-based systems. The Connect Task Force discussed a centralized rental application pilot with Just Economics, aiming to reduce application costs and connect smaller landlords with tenants.
Significant discussion also centered on staffing and leadership following the departure of Paul D’Angelo. Nikki Reed, the new permanent Director of Community and Economic Development, outlined her plan to hire for the vacant Community Development Program Director role and restructure the department. The committee debated the need for a dedicated "Affordable Housing Director" role to prevent burnout and ensure focus. Andy Barnett, Chair of Asheville Area Habitat for Humanity, expressed concern about the span of control, stating, "It's really almost impossible for me to imagine having both of those key strategies [affordable housing and economic development] reporting to one person... It's just, it sounds like a huge span of control."
Councilwoman Mosley raised a proposal to pause new affordable housing funding to better align policies with equity goals, citing a lack of Black developers and residents in current projects. She stated, "The goal is to understand what it is about our policy that is unfairly advantageous to, quite frankly, white men... How can we establish policies that are equitable since that is the stated goal of council... It is uncomfortable. It is scary. But it's necessary to discuss because until now we haven't even discussed it is my point." In response, Barry Bialik, a committee member, expressed hesitation about halting progress, saying, "I personally scares me, the talk of stalling something to try to... fix it... having to pause something that at least is producing some units, you know, scary." The committee discussed the implications of a pause versus implementing an equity scorecard for project review. Additionally, Scott Adams, an urban planner, noted that current rules penalize volume building, stating, "For affordability, volume building is one of the ways to achieve affordability... [The current rules] penalize volume building that there's really no difference. There's still five houses."
Follow-ups
Nikki Reed agreed to check with the bond council to clarify the specific language regarding the November 2023 bond deadline, provide a financial analysis/dashboard of the $25 million bond allocation, and follow up on the flexibility of bond funds for down payment assistance. She also stated she will post the job description for the Community Development Program Director and invite Barry Bialik and a staff member to the interview panel. Reed agreed to share job descriptions from other municipalities, such as Chapel Hill and Ann Arbor, for the Affordable Housing Director role.
Barry Bialik agreed to share the link to the Chapel Hill Affordable Housing Director job description and to post data regarding the percentage of fee rebate houses that are no longer affordable. Margie Bukowski of Weaver Cook Construction agreed to obtain job descriptions for affordable housing directors from other cities, such as Greenville and DHIC, and to provide contact information for Pratt Whitney to the Connect Task Force regarding employer-assisted housing. Paul Heathman of Home Trust Bank agreed to connect the Connect Task Force with Pratt Whitney regarding workforce housing. Councilwoman Mosley stated she will take the equity/pause discussion to the Housing and Community Development committee and Council to define stakeholders and next steps. Finally, Vanilla Savicka of Planning and Zoning confirmed that the Planning and Zoning review for the open space plan has been pushed back one month to February 8 to address urban renewal parcel concerns.
Impact
These discussions highlight the ongoing challenges in balancing the speed of affordable housing production with equity goals and adequate staffing. The clarification of bond fund usage and the restructuring of the Community Development department will influence how the city manages its $25 million affordable housing bond and its long-term housing strategies. The potential shift toward an equity scorecard or a funding pause, as discussed by Councilwoman Mosley, may alter the criteria for future project approvals, while the task force updates indicate a focus on streamlining utility connections and rental applications to improve access for smaller landlords and tenants.
Meeting Video & Transcript