Urban Forestry Commission
September 7, 2021 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 54 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: September 7, 2021
The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission convened on September 7, 2021, to address storm response, ordinance revisions, and urban forest planning. The meeting began with staff reports on the impact of Hurricane Ida and Tropical Storm Fred, the status of the Tree Protection Ordinance, and the Urban Forest Master Plan. The only formal votes taken during the session were the unanimous approval of the previous meeting’s minutes and the unanimous motion to adjourn.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on the legal constraints surrounding "fee-in-lieu" funds, specifically regarding the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance and the Open Space Amendment. Staff explained that public funds cannot be used for private benefit, meaning the city cannot use these funds to help a third party purchase land, such as for the Ravenscroft Preserve, unless the city itself takes ownership. A public commenter expressed disappointment that staff could not immediately identify the total amount of open space fee-in-lieu funds available or who was in charge of them. In response, the Senior Assistant City Attorney confirmed that while the open space ordinance could be amended to allow for more expansive use of funds, such changes would need to go through Planning and Zoning and City Council. Another public commenter raised concerns about enforcement on steep slopes, arguing that current penalties are too lenient for unpermitted tree removal and grading. The Zoning Supervisor noted that while the department has a good track record, it is investigating a specific case on Windswept Drive where trees were removed without a required plan.
The commission also reviewed progress on the UDO Landscaping Standards, specifically regarding Silvacel and third-party inspection certification, and discussed the Urban Place UDO Amendment, which proposes a 25% tree canopy coverage requirement for urban centers. Staff and working groups provided updates on the Policy Working Group’s revisions to Chapter 20/7, the TRC Working Group, and the Budget Request Working Group. Additionally, the commission discussed enforcement actions at 424 Sunset and 409 Sunset regarding tree removal and erosion concerns, as well as the status of state legislation HB 496 regarding local tree protection ordinances.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon by staff and members. The City Arborist agreed to create a document to track tree losses from storms in real-time for crews. The Director of Development Services agreed to account for open space fee-in-lieu funds to ensure they can be used appropriately in reasonable proximity to where they were collected. Staff from Planning and Urban Design agreed to add the discussion on open space fee-in-lieu flexibility to the agenda for the next Open Space Task Force meeting. The Senior Assistant City Attorney agreed to work with the Open Space Task Force to propose draft language for the open space amendment. The Policy Working Group agreed to schedule a meeting within the next month to review recommended changes to Chapter 20, and the Budget Request Working Group agreed to meet weekly starting the following Monday. The Zoning Supervisor agreed to conduct a follow-up site visit at 409 Sunset in a couple of weeks to count trees and verify removals, and to email the contractor regarding soil erosion concerns. Finally, staff agreed to coordinate with the working group to schedule another meeting to work out the details of the Urban Place UDO amendment.
These discussions are relevant to residents as they address the legal mechanisms for funding urban forest projects and the enforcement of tree protection rules on private property. The review of fee-in-lieu funds highlights the ongoing debate over how restricted funds can be utilized for citywide environmental benefits, while the enforcement updates reflect the commission’s attention to compliance with steep slope and tree removal regulations.
Meeting Video & Transcript