Skip to main content
  • 2 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville held a hybrid virtual and in-person meeting on July 6, 2021. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of a development compliance request, staff reports on tree management and new ordinance data, and strategic discussions regarding the city’s budget, master plan, and policy frameworks. The meeting concluded with the adoption of a new mission statement and the approval of a letter to the Planning and Zoning Commission.

Key Decisions

The Commission took four formal votes during the session, all of which passed unanimously. First, the body approved the minutes from the June meeting. Second, the Commission approved a request from Murphy Express at 120 Airport Road for alternative compliance regarding street tree spacing and distance from the road, a deviation necessitated by utility easements. Third, the Commission adopted the draft mission statement (Version 2), including an amendment to explicitly mention the protection of green infrastructure. Finally, the Commission approved a letter to the Planning and Zoning Commission opposing an exemption for building impact trees in the Urban Place district. The meeting was adjourned by a unanimous 6-0 roll call vote.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to strategy for the upcoming budget cycle. The Chair suggested framing the request for a new position as an "urban forestry program coordinator" to emphasize sustainability, while another member advocated for a "senior staff professional" capable of handling complex issues. A third member noted that the term "coordinator" might be more appealing to City Council than "forester," and a Council Member Liaison expressed appreciation for the data the group has compiled to make a compelling case.

Staff presented initial data from the new Tree Protection Ordinance, noting that over 43,800 square feet of canopy have been preserved and 6,160 square feet of planted canopy have been earmarked. The Commission also discussed the structure for spending "fee-in-lieu" funds, with the Director of Development Services indicating there is broad flexibility in how these funds are used and viewing it as an opportunity for the Commission to play a significant role. Additionally, the body reviewed updates on the Urban Forest Master Plan, which is in early stages with GreenWorks, and discussed adding heritage tree protections to the existing ordinance or creating a separate framework.

Regarding the Urban Place UDO Amendment, the Commission discussed a letter opposing an exemption for building impact trees in high-density districts. One member stated that the "one size fits all approach to urban design" denies residents the health and environmental benefits of trees enjoyed in more suburban areas. Staff from Planning and Urban Design clarified that the affected sites, primarily large parking lots, will still include parking lot landscape, street trees, and property line buffers. The Commission also reviewed a new city-wide ethics policy for advisory boards, which outlines procedures for identifying conflicts of interest either at the meeting or prior to it with staff, with the City Attorney’s office available to assist in determinations.

Follow-ups

Several members and staff agreed to specific next steps. The Chair, along with two other members and a representative from GreenWorks, agreed to form a working group to develop strategies for the next budget cycle. The Chair and another member agreed to work with the Assistant City Manager and legal counsel to define the legal parameters and decision matrix for spending fee-in-lieu funds. A group of four members agreed to schedule a face-to-face meeting within the next couple of weeks to begin substantive changes to Chapter 20. Additionally, the Chair agreed to send the adopted mission statement to the city, and the Mission Statement Working Group will meet with staff to determine implementation methods. Staff agreed to submit the approved Urban Place letter to the Planning and Zoning Commission before the 5:00 PM deadline that day, and one member agreed to attend the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting to deliver a three-minute speech on the tree exemption. Another member agreed to keep the Commission updated on a complaint regarding Grove Park/Sunset Mountain as it moves through zoning enforcement.

Impact

These decisions establish the operational direction for the Urban Forestry Commission in the coming months. The adoption of the mission statement and the approval of the letter to the Planning and Zoning Commission signal the Commission’s active role in shaping urban design standards and tree preservation policies. The formation of working groups for budgeting and policy indicates a focus on securing dedicated resources and professional expertise for urban forestry, while the clarification on meeting logistics confirms that the August 3, 2021, meeting will be held in person, with in-person attendance required for all commission members.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches