Skip to main content
  • 3 h 36 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On September 1, 2021, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened to address three primary agenda items: the Biltmore Avenue and McDowell Street corridor studies, a conditional rezoning request for 120/130 Charlotte Street, and the implementation of Phase One of the Urban Centers Initiative. The commission reviewed findings, heard public testimony, and voted on motions regarding transportation planning, mixed-use development, and comprehensive plan updates.

Key Decisions

The commission approved the Biltmore Avenue and McDowell Street corridor studies unanimously, recommending the study for approval by City Council. For the 120/130 Charlotte Street property (formerly Fuddruckers), the commission unanimously approved the conditional rezoning from Community Business 1 to Commercial Expansion Conditional Zone, finding the mixed-use development reasonable and consistent with the city’s comprehensive plan.

The most contentious decision involved Phase One of the Urban Centers Initiative, which involves rezoning approximately 122 acres across four nodes to a new "Urban Place Form District." The commission voted 6-1 to approve the rezoning, with an amendment lowering the threshold for mandatory housing requirements from 10 acres to 5 acres. Following this, the commission voted 4-3 to approve associated code amendments to Chapter 7 of the Asheville Code of Ordinances, incorporating the same 5-acre housing requirement.

Discussion Highlights

During the corridor study discussion, staff from VHB described the recommendations as a "menu of options" for the city. City transportation staff noted a lack of recent traffic counts in that part of Asheville, expressing concern about the data.

Regarding the Charlotte Street project, staff recommended approval, citing the project's strategic location and higher density residential infill. Members of the commission discussed the project's architecture, with one member criticizing it as a "donut that doesn't have any penetrations" while applauding the inclusion of 20% affordable housing. Other members praised the developer's willingness to collaborate on recommendations, such as moving the garage entrance and adding street trees, contrasting this cooperative approach with a previous project that was presented as a "yes or no" proposal.

The Urban Centers Initiative generated significant debate over the balance between mandatory rezoning and incentives. Staff explained that they felt compelled to use a "big stick approach" because there was likely no "carrot" large enough to encourage redevelopment consistent with the comprehensive plan. One commissioner argued that the current regulations were "choking" the city and that change was necessary, while another expressed concern that the proposal allowed too much leeway for existing development patterns to continue. Staff countered that they had reached a "sweet spot" that would allow sites to naturally transition over time.

Community Input

Public comment on the corridor studies and the Charlotte Street project was limited or non-existent, with no live call-ins or written submissions recorded for the latter. For the Urban Centers Initiative, general public comment had been taken previously, so only representatives of affected property owners spoke. A representative for Avon Partners expressed concern that proposed street standards would eliminate too much parking, making retail redevelopment unviable, and requested one additional month to consult with engineers. Staff clarified that the provided dimensions included street trees and that the current drive aisle width was already approximately 31 feet.

Representatives for Ingalls Markets and BPG Family Holdings argued that requiring wider streets would make redevelopment financially prohibitive, citing examples of successful redevelopments that lacked mandated wide streets or residential components. They advocated for a collaborative, incentive-based process rather than mandatory rezoning, with one representative stating, "This is a complete involuntary rezoning... This is not an incentive, this is a hammer." Staff responded that some cited examples were currently non-compliant with existing code and that the proposed plans still resulted in large, single-use developments without housing, contradicting the comprehensive plan. Staff indicated they did not believe an additional month of delay would resolve the property owners' concerns.

Follow-ups

Staff committed to presenting the corridor study to City Council in the next month or so and to work through MPO and NCDOT processes to fund a portion of the recommendations. Staff also agreed to check crash data for the Caledonia Road intersection and provide a response to the commission.

For the Charlotte Street project, the applicant agreed to work with Duke Energy to move utility poles underground and relocate transformers, and confirmed that trash would be compacted inside the building. Staff stated that a revised Traffic Impact Analysis model was being updated and would be submitted for review soon, and that a report on tree health standards was expected to go to council within a month or two.

Regarding the Urban Centers Initiative, staff indicated they were ready to move the item to City Council, noting that three years of collaboration had occurred. Staff also noted that focus groups had been held to gather feedback on potential incentive-based approaches for the second phase of the initiative.

Impact

These decisions impact the future development and transportation infrastructure of Asheville. The approval of the corridor studies provides a framework for improving transportation on Biltmore Avenue and McDowell Street. The rezoning of 120/130 Charlotte Street allows for a mixed-use development with 20% affordable housing in a strategic location. The Phase One Urban Centers Initiative rezoning and code amendments aim to encourage mixed-use development, walkability, and housing supply in key urban nodes, marking a significant shift in the city's approach to urban planning and development regulations.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches