Planning & Zoning Commission
October 6, 2021 at 4:59 PM
- 2 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On October 6, 2021, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened to address six agenda items, including the approval of previous minutes, the election of new officers, and reviews of specific development projects. The commission voted on a conditional zoning amendment, a large-scale rezoning proposal, and two ministerial site plan reviews.
Key Decisions
The commission began by unanimously approving the minutes from the September 21, 2021 meeting. Following this, the body unanimously elected new officers, with Commissioner Archibald serving as Chair and Commissioner Levi as Vice Chair.
Regarding development requests, the commission voted 6-0 to deny a request to remove a condition prohibiting drive-throughs at 511 Brevard Road, recommending denial to City Council. The commission then voted 6-1 to approve the rezoning of approximately 128 acres, including the Asheville Mall area, to the Urban Place Form District under the Urban Centers Initiative Phase 2. Commissioner Barton cast the sole "Nay" vote on this item.
In ministerial reviews, the commission voted 6-1 to recommend approval of the site plan for a new 115-room hotel at 51 Biltmore Avenue, with Commissioner Bubenik voting "Nay." Similarly, the commission voted 6-1 to recommend approval of the site plan for an 80-unit micro-apartment building at 217 Hilliard Avenue, with Commissioner Hoke voting "Nay."
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the 511 Brevard Road drive-through request, Chair Archibald expressed hesitation to remove the condition without a site plan demonstrating how the drive-through would function, stating, "My big concern is that without any site plan that shows how the drive-through would work... I'm really hesitant to remove that condition right now." Commissioner Rodriguez also opposed the request, noting, "I just don't buy the argument that you have to do this simply because there are potential lessees."
For the Urban Centers Initiative Phase 2 rezoning, Commissioner Barton questioned the urgency of rezoning this specific stretch while other areas had not been evaluated simultaneously. Staff member Videla Sotvika explained that the department is prioritizing locations on the highest frequency transit network because they offer the "biggest bang for our buck."
In the review of the 217 Hilliard Avenue micro-apartments, Commissioner Barton highlighted the density, calculating that 80 units on 0.18 acres equates to about 440 units per acre, and remarked, "That level of density... is not scary when you look at it. This is a great project." Staff member Shannon Tuck clarified that the 51 Biltmore Avenue hotel bypassed the conditional zoning process because it met technical standards, incorporated public benefits, and received a positive design review recommendation.
Community Input
A public commenter, a resident of the Kenilworth neighborhood, raised concerns regarding the Urban Centers Initiative Phase 2 rezoning. The resident cited issues with overdevelopment, loss of natural environment, and inadequate stormwater management, specifically mentioning sediment runoff into Ross Creek and the lake. The commenter requested that the city exercise forethought regarding infrastructure and environmental impact.
Staff member Videla Sotvika responded by noting that staff worked with the Coalition for Asheville Neighborhoods, who supported the project after building heights were reduced to address shadow and view concerns. Sotvika also mentioned that the Planning and Urban Design department is working on an open space ordinance scheduled for December, which will increase stormwater capture requirements, and that tree preservation language is being updated. Commissioner Faircloth shared the commenter’s concerns regarding stormwater and erosion, noting his personal experience with damage to waterways. Chair Archibald suggested that densifying the region may help the environment by reducing the need for new road construction and hillside development. No public comments were received for the ministerial review items.
Follow-ups
Staff recommended that the applicant for 511 Brevard Road consider a site plan revision that minimizes pedestrian impacts if they wish to pursue the drive-through in the future. For the 51 Biltmore Avenue hotel, staff and the applicant met the day after the commission meeting to discuss blocking vehicular access to the alley to prioritize pedestrian and bike movement while maintaining off-street loading; staff will also review the proposed new transit shelter design for ADA compliance. For the 217 Hilliard Avenue residential building, staff will work with the architect to ensure adequate site lighting and address the preservation or replacement of granite curb during final technical review, while the applicant will finalize details on trash collection before permitting. Additionally, staff confirmed that three corridor studies (Hendersonville Road, Biltmore Avenue, and Tunnel Road) have been continued to City Council for evaluation, likely at their November meeting.
Impact
These decisions reflect the commission's balancing of development density with environmental and pedestrian safety concerns. The denial of the drive-through at 511 Brevard Road prioritizes pedestrian safety and carbon reduction goals outlined in the comprehensive plan. Conversely, the approval of the Urban Centers Initiative Phase 2 rezoning and the two ministerial site plans supports increased housing and commercial development in central Asheville, subject to technical conditions regarding stormwater, lighting, and traffic management.
Meeting Video & Transcript