Downtown Commission
August 13, 2021 at 9:30 AM
- 1 h 19 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: August 13, 2021
The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on August 13, 2021, to review public comments, discuss a draft development impact checklist, and address proposals regarding downtown infrastructure and policies. The agenda included updates from the Design Review Committee, the Downtown Association, and staff reports on hotel policies, noise ordinances, parking rates, and emergency shelter initiatives.
Key Decisions The commission voted to approve the minutes from the June 11, 2021 meeting. The motion passed 7-3, with three members abstaining because they were not present at the previous meeting. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was voted on and passed unanimously.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposal for facade changes at 18 Broadway. Members debated the preservation of historical architectural elements, specifically the building’s parapet and transoms. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher questioned why the parapet was being removed during the design phase, noting it is an iconic feature of the building. Commissioner Robin Raines expressed strong support for reinstalling transoms to preserve the building's history. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson praised the project, describing the arched windows on the lower level as beautiful and appealing. Commissioner Guillermo Rodriguez raised concerns about a trip hazard created by the recessed entrance, to which a staff member responded that building safety and code issues would address the matter.
The commission also discussed the reestablishment of formal subcommittees, such as Public Space Management and Parking, to ensure greater public engagement and transparency compared to informal working groups. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher expressed interest in continuing to chair the Public Space Management committee, citing the upcoming end of the shared space initiative as a timely reason to do so. Additionally, staff provided updates on the new noise ordinance, which was approved by City Council on July 27 and takes effect on September 15. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson commented on the intensity of sound on Patton Avenue, while Commissioner Andrew Fletcher noted that his attorney described the ordinance as "pro-citizen."
Community Input Two written public comments were reviewed during the meeting. One commenter, representing a downtown business, requested specific guidance and help regarding mask mandates. The Chair noted that both Buncombe County and City Council planned to introduce a mask mandate, but no further specific action was taken by the commission at that time. A second commenter asked about changes to hotel development following the moratorium, expressing concern that every project seems to be approved. In response, a staff member stated that Planning and Zoning considers every properly filed project and that the city had tightened the process by reducing the number of locations where hotels could be requested. Another staff member noted that the hotel plan includes "negative points" in the impact matrix for projects that displace existing businesses. Commissioner Sage Turner informed the group that City Council would review the hotel overlay district in September as a six-month check-in.
Follow-ups Staff confirmed that the draft development impact checklist is a working document that will be modified as the commission applies it, and it is not being formally adopted at this time. Regarding the parking working group, Commissioner Megan Rogers offered to step in as a commission member to co-lead or chair the group if needed, after a non-commission member agreed to help lead it. Staff agreed to send a meeting holdout for a proposed work session with the Multimodal Committee scheduled for Wednesday, October 27, at 3:00 PM to discuss parklets, shared streets, and public space guidelines. Additionally, staff agreed to check on the city’s vacancies page to ensure the new Noise Ordinance Advisory Board vacancy is listed.
Impact These discussions highlight the commission’s ongoing efforts to balance development with the preservation of Asheville’s downtown character. The review of the 18 Broadway project and the debate over subcommittee structures reflect a focus on maintaining historical integrity and ensuring transparent public engagement. The updates on the noise ordinance and hotel policies provide residents with insight into how the city is managing quality-of-life issues and commercial growth in the downtown area.
Meeting Video & Transcript