Design Review Committee
July 15, 2021 at 11:59 AM
- 1 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On July 15, 2021, the City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting to address administrative items, review design projects, and discuss future logistics. The committee focused on approving previous minutes, establishing a schedule for in-person meetings, and evaluating three specific development projects: an auto body repair shop, a beer garden and warehouse renovation, and a mixed-use building.
Key Decisions The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting as amended, with the correction changing the status of Chair Jane Matthews from present to absent. The vote was recorded with three members voting aye, one abstaining, and one absent. By consensus, the committee also decided to hold in-person meetings at 12:30 PM on the third Thursday of each month, starting in the North Conference Room on the first floor of City Hall.
Regarding project approvals, the committee voted to recommend approval for the auto body repair shop at 17 Truckers Place. The vote resulted in five ayes and one abstention. The committee unanimously recommended approval for the beer garden and warehouse renovation at 284 Lyman Street. The mixed-use building at 44 Collier Avenue was reviewed informally and is not yet approved; it is scheduled to go to the Traffic Review Committee next and will return to the Design Review Committee in September at the earliest.
Discussion Highlights During the review of 17 Truckers Place, Karen Craig-Nolan abstained from voting, stating that the committee was working with incomplete data because the FEMA flood maps used were dated 2010. Jeremy Goldstein questioned whether holding every project hostage until flood maps are updated is fair, while Megan Vieren from the applicant team noted that the FEMA website still shows the 2010 effective date, indicating nothing has changed to date.
For the 284 Lyman Street project, Steven Lee Johnson suggested that the design team take advantage of the site’s industrial nature by creating a landscape that reflects that character, noting it might push ordinance limits but could be worth trying. In the informal review of 44 Collier Avenue, Kimberly Hunter expressed excitement about the elevations and materials, calling it "smart design." Robin Raines praised the concept of a food truck on the roof but asked if the brick would be aged to look old, as new-looking brick with offset windows did not fit the concept. Eric Howell from the applicant team confirmed the intention is to make the building look as if it has been added to over a hundred years. Staff member Sasha expressed a preference for shallower balconies that do not extend over the sidewalk.
Follow-ups A staff member agreed to check with Steph Monsendal regarding the status of funding to update the design guidelines, which currently date from the 1990s or 2010, and to send an email update to the committee. The applicant team for 44 Collier Avenue stated they have completed their neighborhood meeting.
Impact These decisions allow the auto body repair shop and the beer garden renovation to proceed with their respective designs, which the committee found meet the intent of the River District design review guidelines. The mixed-use building at 44 Collier Avenue remains in the review process, with its next step being a traffic review before returning to the Design Review Committee in September. Additionally, the establishment of a regular in-person meeting schedule and the inquiry into updating outdated design guidelines will shape the committee's operations and standards for future projects.
Meeting Video & Transcript