Skip to main content
  • 1 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Recap: August 19, 2021

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on August 19, 2021, to review four development projects. The agenda included two formal Level 1 design reviews and two informal preliminary reviews. The committee began by approving the minutes from the July 15, 2021 meeting via a unanimous vote.

The first formal review concerned a renovation of a historic building at 18 Broadway Street, which dates to approximately 1912–1915. The proposal to house a new restaurant involved replacing the lower storefront, adding a recessed entrance, and removing the historic gabled parapet. Committee members debated the preservation of these historic elements, with specific focus on the parapet and potential transom windows. Chair Jane Matthews expressed concern about whether the design fit the texture and context of Asheville, noting that staff supported the design if the gabled parapet could be kept. Brian Moffitt stated that the parapet was a historically significant piece of the building and that he would support the project only if it was retained. Jeremy Goldstein clarified that approval would demonstrate the committee’s collective view that the applicant should keep the parapet, though it would not legally prevent the applicant from proceeding otherwise. The committee voted 5 ayes and 1 nay to recommend approval of the project with the condition that the historic gabled parapet is retained. Jane Matthews cast the sole "nay" vote but stated the motion was carried.

The second formal review addressed an addition to the New Belgium Brewing facility, which includes a canopy over an existing beer garden, a deck expansion, and a roof over an existing rear deck. The project also features new landscaping with oak trees and witch hazels. Staff noted that the design aligns with the existing brewery aesthetic and had been previously reviewed by the Riverfront Commission. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of the deck and canopy project.

The committee also conducted informal reviews for two additional projects. For 217 Hilliard Street, a proposed five-story mixed-use building, discussion focused on massing, materials, and streetscape improvements, including a new 10-foot sidewalk and widened bike lane. Specific points of debate included the delineation of the main entrance, a "wing" roof feature, and lighting standards. Chair Jane Matthews expressed a personal bias against fiber cement in downtown, noting it is not a very urban material, though she acknowledged the guidelines allow it. Brian Moffitt suggested that the pedestrian entrance could be more strongly delineated from the exit using the overhanging structure. Regarding murals, a council liaison suggested that applicants work through the City’s public art program rather than having the Design Review Committee approve specific art pieces.

For 48 South Market Street, the informal review covered a proposal to add a third story to a narrow historic building, creating two residential units and ground-floor office space. The design involves setting back the new floor, using brick to match the neighboring Foundry Hotel, and rebuilding the deteriorating rear facade. No formal vote was taken on this item as it was in preliminary review.

No public comments were received during the session. Staff reported that there were no callers in the queue for public comment on either the 18 Broadway Street or New Belgium Brewing items, and no general public comments were received at the end of the meeting.

Several follow-up actions were identified during the informal reviews. For 217 Hilliard Street, staff member Sasha agreed to look into how to handle mural approvals, potentially encouraging applicants to use the City’s public art program, and to find information on street lighting standards to bring back to the committee. The applicant team indicated they are heading toward a formal design review in September. For 48 South Market Street, the applicant stated she would submit the project formally, likely in October, as the September agenda was full, and agreed to provide renderings that include the building behind it for better context. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn made by Jeremy Goldstein and seconded by Brian Moffitt.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches