Board of Adjustment
June 28, 2021 at 2:00 PM
- 38 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On June 28, 2021, the City of Asheville Board of Adjustment convened to address a single agenda item: a request for a variance regarding on-premises signage at 14 O. Henry Avenue, the building formerly known as the Asheville Citizen-Times. The meeting focused on determining how to handle the existing "Asheville Citizen-Times" sign in relation to the building’s sign square footage limits, which would allow a new tenant to install additional signage.
Key Decisions The Board first voted unanimously (5 Ayes) to approve the minutes from the April 2021 meeting. Regarding the signage request, the Board voted unanimously (5 Ayes) to determine that the existing "Asheville Citizen-Times" sign is "historic" as defined by Section 7-13-11 of the City’s Unified Development Ordinance. Chair Paul Wilczynski moved for this determination. By classifying the sign as historic, the Board did not issue a formal variance; instead, this factual determination allows staff to treat the existing sign as exempt from square footage calculations, thereby permitting the new sign to be installed within legal limits.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented the issue by explaining that while the existing sign is integrated into the building’s facade, staff could not unilaterally classify it as exempt because it currently advertises an active tenant. However, staff noted that if the sign were classified as "historic"—defined as existing prior to August 28, 1990, and permanently integrated—it would be exempt. Assistant City Attorney Eric Edgerton clarified that the Board had two options: issue a variance based on the spirit of the ordinance or determine the sign is historic. Edgerton stated, "If the board were to reach that finding [that the sign is historic], staff hasn’t done anything to contradict that. So we really are leaving it in your hands."
The petitioner, Peter Schaefer of Citizen Vinyl, explained that the business invested approximately $3 million in the building and needs better visibility to attract customers, especially post-COVID. He noted that the current sign occupies about 50 square feet of the 75 square foot limit, leaving little room for their new sign. A public commenter, CEO of Citizen Vinyl, emphasized the desire to honor the building’s history while increasing business visibility, noting that Citizen Vinyl is now the building’s largest tenant. Property owner Nathan Brown stated that the building is a contributing structure in the downtown National Register District and affirmed that the owners support the design, which preserves the historic sign while adding the new one.
During the discussion, Board member Bill Newman expressed difficulty in understanding where the "unnecessary hardship" required for a variance would result from a strict application of the ordinance, given that staff had not previously considered the sign exempt. Suzanne Vernon Godsey stated, "I feel like it’s always gonna be called the Asheville Citizen Times building no matter what... I think it is historic... So I’m in favor of however you all want to grant this variance or make a determination that it’s historic." Chair Paul Wilczynski added, "I am in favor of approving things which speak to the future of Asheville."
Community Input There were no public comments from residents or callers during the public comment period. The chair stated, "We don’t have any callers on the 1... No callers."
Follow-ups Following the Board’s determination that the sign is historic, staff will issue the permit for the new Citizen Vinyl sign, treating the existing Citizen-Times sign as exempt from the square footage limit. No further action is required from the Board.
Impact This decision resolves the signage capacity issue for the building at 14 O. Henry Avenue. By determining the existing sign is historic, the Board allowed the new tenant, Citizen Vinyl, to install a new sign (approximately 51.5 square feet) without exceeding the district’s maximum allowance of 75 square feet. This outcome permits the new business to increase its visibility while preserving the historic character of the building’s facade.
Meeting Video & Transcript