Board of Adjustment
August 30, 2021 at 1:59 PM
- 28 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held a virtual meeting on August 30, 2021. The agenda consisted of one evidentiary hearing regarding a variance request and the approval of minutes from a previous meeting.
The primary item of discussion was a request for a 100% variance from required off-street parking standards for a commercial property at 227 Haywood Road. Petitioners Charles Pinkerton and Judy McGuire argued that the 1,044-square-foot lot, built in 1926, is physically incapable of meeting parking requirements because the building occupies the entire space. They presented an email from the Transportation Director confirming that the City has no plans to change traffic patterns or add on-street parking in the area. The petitioners contended that without the variance, the property cannot be reasonably used or sold, as prospective buyers would be required to meet impossible on-site parking standards. Staff from the Development Services Department noted that while landscaping waivers might be available through the Urban Forestry Commission and sidewalk deficiencies could potentially be addressed via a fee-in-lieu option, adding a single on-street parking space was not feasible due to proximity to an intersection and the inability to reserve the space for exclusive business use.
The Board voted to grant the variance for 227 Haywood Road. Paul Wilczynski moved to grant the request, which was seconded by another board member. The vote was 5 Yes and 0 No. Chair Pratip Bhakta noted that the Board of Adjustment is a quasi-judicial body and that a four-fifths vote is required to grant a variance. Suzanne Vernon Godsey stated she was satisfied with the physical constraints and the lack of on-street parking options. Judy McGuire stated that the petitioners had met the test of unnecessary hardship and requested approval.
The Board also reviewed and approved the minutes from the June meeting. A board member moved to approve the minutes, and the Chair seconded the motion. The vote was 5 Yes and 0 No. Two members who were not present at the June meeting stated they would vote yes to approve the minutes.
The Chair opened the floor for public comment, but a staff member reported that there were no members of the public on the line. Consequently, no public comments were received.
No explicit follow-ups were assigned during the meeting. The variance was granted, the minutes were approved, and the meeting was adjourned.
Meeting Video & Transcript