Skip to main content
  • 2 h 43 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Design Review Committee Meeting Recap: June 3, 2021

The City of Asheville Design Review Committee held a virtual meeting on June 3, 2021, to review four development projects and handle administrative items. The committee initially lacked a quorum until a member joined by phone, allowing the body to proceed with the first three projects. Attendance dropped later in the meeting, resulting in a loss of quorum for the final project, which was postponed.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from May 20, 2021, and adopted the committee’s rules and procedures. Regarding development projects, the committee unanimously approved the design for a three-story brick building at 57 Roberts Street and exterior modifications to a 1940s brick building at 240 Clingman Avenue Extension. For the six-story mixed-use building at 159 & 144 Riverside Drive, the committee voted unanimously to recommend approval subject to specific revisions. These conditions require establishing a clear pedestrian pass-through in accordance with the form code, providing vegetative screening in the parking lot, adjusting sidewalk widths to 8 feet, and prohibiting project or district identification signage on the historic smokestack. The committee did not take a formal vote on the 9-story mixed-use building at Biltmore & South Market due to a lack of quorum; this item was postponed to the June 17 meeting for an initial design discussion.

Discussion Highlights Significant debate centered on the 159 & 144 Riverside Drive project, specifically regarding "punch-through" openings and building length. Member Brian Moffitt expressed that while he admired the design, the glassed-in openings did not meet the intent of the form code, which he interpreted as requiring actual breaks in the building massing. Member Robin Raines agreed, stating that the glass did not visually read as a break. Chair Jane Matthews criticized the parking placement, noting it was inconsistent with design guidelines because the lot on 144 butted the street without justification. Regarding the 57 Roberts Street project, Chair Jane Matthews noted that the proposed tan brick was incompatible with the surrounding red brick facades. For the postponed 9-story building, the discussion focused on step-back requirements, material selection, and entrance clarity.

Community Input Public comment was received for three of the four projects. For 57 Roberts Street, a public commenter asked about building height relative to the form-based code and noted they did not mind the lighter brick color. Staff clarified the zoning height limit is 45 feet, and the architect confirmed the building is 43 feet tall. For 159 & 144 Riverside Drive, a public commenter raised concerns about underground cisterns, the placement of the Brownfield Agreement, glass on the parking area, the plan for the original boiler, and opposition to any written item on the smokestack. Staff and applicants responded by clarifying that the smokestack signage was intended for district identification, confirming no glass would be placed on ground-floor parking, and stating the historic boiler would be kept. Members Jane Matthews and Brian Moffitt agreed that the smokestack should not have signage or art. For the 9-story building, a public commenter asked how pedestrians and wheelchairs would access the building given the lack of sidewalk on one side. Member Brian Moffitt noted sidewalks exist on the two street sides, and the applicant clarified that all parking is private and accessible via an internal elevator.

Follow-Ups Staff agreed to clarify the interpretation of step-back requirements for the 9-story building and to update the staff report regarding design guideline compliance. The applicant for the 9-story building agreed to provide more detailed renderings of the residential and retail entrances for the June 17 meeting. For the Riverside Drive project, the applicant agreed to revise the site plan to show an 8-foot sidewalk to widen the planting strip and move plantings for better vegetative screening. Another applicant representative agreed to make adjustments to the "punch-through" openings to better meet the intent of the form code. Staff indicated they could connect the applicant with appropriate parties to explore district identification signage, though the final vote excluded smokestack signage.

Impact These decisions impact the visual character and usability of the downtown and riverside areas. The approval of the Riverside Drive project, subject to revisions, ensures that the new six-story building will include a direct pedestrian connection from the front to the rear of the lot and will preserve the historic mill building and smokestack without commercial signage. The postponement of the 9-story building allows for further review of accessibility and design guidelines before a formal decision is made.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches