Skip to main content
  • 2 h 34 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview The City of Asheville Design Review Committee met on May 20, 2021, to review four development projects. The agenda included two formal design reviews and two informal design reviews, focusing on projects within the Riverfront Design Review District and the Central Business District. The committee also approved the draft action minutes from a previous meeting.

Key Decisions The committee approved two formal design projects. For the Redwood Commons project, a 70-unit senior living apartment complex at 21 Governors View Road, the committee voted unanimously (7-0) to recommend approval with conditions. The conditions required the applicant to incorporate changes regarding the articulation of material heights, investigate the heights of different roof elements, and break up the large east elevation wall. For the Artful Way project, a mixed-use development at 31 Artful Way, the committee voted unanimously (4-0) to recommend approval as presented. Three members recused themselves from this vote due to associations with the applicant. Additionally, the committee unanimously approved the draft action minutes from March 17, 2022. No formal votes were taken on the two informal design review items.

Discussion Highlights During the formal review of Redwood Commons, staff supported the proposed design, noting it was generally in keeping with the character of the district. However, a committee member noted that the current design appeared to be "turning its back" on the primary corridor, Swananoa River Road, and suggested the south elevation needed more articulation. For the Artful Way project, the discussion focused on design refinements made since an earlier informal review, including a subtler gradient on the metal siding and different panel profiles to provide contrast.

In the informal review of 226 Hilliard Avenue, a large residential building, members raised concerns about the urban heat island effect and the building’s massing. One member emphasized the need for a green roof, stating, "This is a green roof site. This is a green roof opportunity." Another member criticized the Hilliard Avenue elevation, stating, "This corner is not right at all... It’s just totally the wrong move," and suggested the building elements needed to "land" on the ground rather than hovering. A third member commented that the building felt like a "fortress" that separated from the urban context.

For the 72 Broadway Street project (The Create Project), the committee discussed facade design, material articulation, and public realm improvements. Members expressed concern that the changes in materials (brick, metal, fiber cement) created a "jigsaw" or "frenetic" appearance lacking a clear system. The committee also discussed the environmental benefits of green roofs, with staff noting potential stormwater volume reductions of up to 87%. Additionally, the committee noted that current downtown design guidelines may be outdated, specifically regarding conflicts with dark sky initiatives.

Community Input A public commenter, representing property owners, spoke regarding the 72 Broadway Street project. The commenter opposed the use of a private alley behind the Masonic Temple for any access to the development, arguing that the alley is a deeded access not maintained by the city and that the developer may not have the legal right to use it for traffic control or entry. No specific member or staff member responded directly to these legal arguments in the transcript.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to check with the director regarding a feasible timeframe for updating the downtown and riverfront design guidelines. One committee member stated they plan to attend the upcoming board and commission restructuring kickoff meeting to represent the committee. While project teams for the informal reviews agreed to revisit ideas such as green roofs and window styles, these are actions by the applicants rather than the committee.

Impact These decisions and discussions impact the architectural character and environmental sustainability of Asheville’s Riverfront and Central Business District. The approval of Redwood Commons and Artful Way allows these mixed-use and senior living projects to proceed with specific design modifications. The feedback provided on the Hilliard Avenue and Broadway Street projects will guide the developers as they refine their designs, with a particular focus on mitigating heat, improving street-level engagement, and managing stormwater through green infrastructure.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches