Urban Forestry Commission
June 1, 2021 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: June 1, 2021
The City of Asheville Urban Forestry Commission convened on June 1, 2021, to review alternative compliance requests, discuss the city’s upcoming budget, and update members on ongoing legislative and planning initiatives. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the previous May meeting, which was approved unanimously by a vote of 6 ayes.
The Commission voted to approve three alternative compliance requests, allowing specific projects to deviate from standard landscaping requirements. For 110 Airport Road, the Commission unanimously approved (6 ayes) a request to place street trees approximately 40 feet from the street rather than the standard 20 feet, due to existing utility easements. For the Dr. Wesley Grant Senior Center at 285 Livingston Street, the Commission unanimously approved (6 ayes) a request to distribute buffer yard planting requirements throughout the site instead of creating a continuous 20-foot buffer along Depot Street, in order to preserve existing mature trees. Finally, for 301 Merriman Avenue, the Commission unanimously approved (6 ayes) a request to reduce the width of a required Type A buffer from 20 feet to 10 feet in specific areas, utilizing a combination of vegetation and a fence due to existing building placement.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the city’s upcoming budget, specifically the lack of funding for an Urban Forester position and an Urban Forest Master Plan. Vice Chair Patrick Gilbert expressed the need to press ahead to encourage City Council to seriously consider funding an urban forester, noting that the city continues to lose trees at an unsustainable rate. Ed Macy voiced frustration regarding the budget process, questioning what more the Commission could do to convince City Council to prioritize the issue after conducting their research. Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, explained that the budget process involves prioritizing departmental requests that often exceed the city’s available funds. City Council Member Kim Roney responded by expressing appreciation for the Commission’s work and stated that the next step for Council would be to review how the tree canopy preservation ordinance is working.
During the general public comment period, a resident raised concerns about a potential loophole in the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, arguing that properties under two acres are exempt and could be subdivided by developers, leading to significant tree loss without protection. The commenter urged the Commission to investigate this issue. Vice Chair Patrick Gilbert responded by noting that a state exemption applies to properties of two acres or less, and while the city may not have considered the subdivision angle when creating the exemption, the Commission needs to pay attention to it as an unintended consequence. Ed Macy suggested adding the issue to a list of items to revisit at the end of the year, and Chair Amy Smith agreed to add it to the list of items to monitor with data.
The Commission also voted unanimously (6 ayes) to support a resolution urging City Council to remain opposed to the enactment of Senate Bill 349 and House Bill 401, which are state bills related to tree canopy. The resolution was forwarded to City Council. Additionally, the Commission received updates on the Urban Place UDO Amendment regarding zoning changes for mixed-use districts, and on the Windswept Drive zoning enforcement case involving unauthorized tree removal. A student from UNC Asheville presented research on the economic and social significance of Asheville’s urban tree canopy, and Asheville Greenworks introduced initial steps for the Urban Forest Master Plan.
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Ed Macy agreed to relay the public comment regarding the subdivision loophole to Chris Collins, Assistant Director of Planning & Urban Design, so it can be added to a list of issues to evaluate later in the year. Chair Amy Smith agreed to have staff connect with Sharon Summerall to help her understand how to use GIS tree canopy mapping tools. Ed Macy also agreed to send the initial markup of Chapter 20 to Chair Amy Smith. Nancy Watford, staff, agreed to look into providing bound copies of the Site Development Standards Manual for the Policy Working Group, and to add a Commission member to the notification list for Technical Review Committee meetings. Monty Clampett, Site Inspection and Zoning Enforcement Coordinator, agreed to check the status of a stormwater impoundment on the Windswept Drive property, and Valerie Wellborn, Stormwater Capital Projects, agreed to determine if wood from trees removed for stormwater projects will be repurposed or sent to landfill. Nancy Watford also agreed to send meeting invitations for the upcoming Urban Forest Master Plan foundational meeting to Commission members who requested them.
Meeting Video & Transcript