Human Relations Commission
April 15, 2021 at 5:31 PM
- 1 h 31 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: April 15, 2021
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville met on April 15, 2021, to receive updates from its working groups and plan for future community engagement. The agenda focused on three primary areas: the ongoing review of homeless encampments, the formation of a new working group on reparations, and the development of a communications plan. Additionally, the commission discussed logistical preparations for a June retreat and the search for a new Equity Director.
Key Decisions The commission made two formal procedural motions during the meeting. First, a motion was made to have a member take minutes for the session; no formal vote was recorded, but the chair accepted the offer. Second, a motion to adjourn was made and seconded, and the chair declared the meeting adjourned. No other formal votes or motions to adopt recommendations were recorded.
Discussion Highlights The Homeless Encampments Working Group reported on interviews conducted with city staff, police, and non-profit partners, including Beloved Asheville and Homeward Bound. The group discussed the complexity of removing encampments, the city’s adherence to CDC guidelines during the pandemic, and recent mass evictions on city property. A member of the working group stated, "We don't support the seven-day removal process of all the city encampments... Not only did these evictions damage the human relations between the city and our houseless people, but it's also damaged the relations to organizations and mutual aid groups."
A new working group was established to address reparations and the allocation of COVID-19 relief funds to the Black community. A commissioner expressed urgency regarding the issue, stating, "I feel like the city council members are going to push this to the side and the black community is going to be put back under the bus... It's time for us to get what we deserve." Councilwoman Kim Rooney noted that reparations were named a top four priority and commented, "It seems appropriate that this group if it wanted to make a recommendation with a formal working group should do it as soon as feasibly possible." Another commissioner emphasized the need for careful process, stating, "I do not believe in rushing people to decisions... I want to see something that is gonna be permanent in this city instead of just rushing something... We need to give people due diligence."
The commission also received an update on the development of a communications plan, which will utilize the City’s Communications and Public Engagement (CAPE) department as a resource. Staff clarified legal constraints regarding shared documents, noting, "What we don't want you to do is have a document where multiple people have access to editing it... If the full group is doing that, you likely are going to be seen as having a group meeting, and that would be in violation, potentially, of the open meetings law." Finally, the commission discussed planning a retreat for late June, which will be held in-person if vaccination rates allow, otherwise virtually. The search for a new Equity Director was also discussed, with the City Manager’s office having outsourced the search to a national firm.
Community Input No public comments were recorded in this transcript. The chair and staff confirmed that no members of the public had signed up or called in to speak during the public comment period.
Follow-ups Several specific follow-up actions were agreed upon by members and staff:
- The Homeless Encampments Working Group agreed to provide written recommendations to the full commission for the next meeting.
- The chair agreed to support the formation of the reparations working group. Councilwoman Kim Rooney committed to asking the City Manager’s office formally about the timeline for including reparations recommendations in the current budget process and sending that information to the group.
- The member leading the communications working group stated they would contact the Director of Communications & Public Engagement to begin building a plan and report back to the commission.
- The chair offered to add interested members to the RSVP list for a statewide meeting of local human relations commissions scheduled for April 27.
- Staff agreed to take a recommendation from a commissioner to the City Manager regarding allowing community input on the selection of the new Equity Director.
Impact This meeting advanced the commission’s strategic goals by formalizing a new working group on reparations and setting a timeline for the homeless encampments working group to deliver written recommendations. The discussions highlight the commission's focus on balancing urgent community needs, such as housing and racial equity, with the procedural requirements of open meetings law and budget timelines. The establishment of a communications plan and the planning of a June retreat indicate a continued effort to improve internal coordination and public engagement for the remainder of the year.
Meeting Video & Transcript