Human Relations Commission
March 18, 2021 at 5:46 PM
- 1 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville voted to recommend that the Asheville City Council remove the Vance Monument within 90 days. The motion passed with 11 votes in favor, 1 vote against, and 1 abstention. Under North Carolina public body rules, abstentions are counted as "yes" votes for the tally. The commission also elected new officers, with Tonya Rodriguez elected as Chair and Brandon Oliver elected as Vice Chair. A motion to adjourn was made and seconded, and the chair accepted the motion to close the meeting.
Discussion Highlights
The commission spent significant time debating the timeline for the Vance Monument removal. Chair Tonya Rodriguez stated that 90 days is a "pretty generous amount of time" for bids to come in and for the monument to be removed. Commissioner Dolores Venable, who voted against the motion, questioned whether 90 days was a realistic timeframe or if the language should be framed as a demand rather than a recommendation. Commissioner Davidson Jones, who abstained, asked staff where they currently stood in the process regarding the monument. Commissioner Daniel Young voted against the motion, arguing that it should not take 90 days to remove the statue and that waiting longer would provide excuses for further delays.
Staff provided updates on the Office of Equity and Inclusion, noting that the office is currently down to two employees while they cover the position and activate an employee group to assist with work until new hires are made. Staff member Richard White indicated that a consultant is handling the search for the new Director of Equity and Inclusion. Regarding the disparity study, Commissioner Davidson Jones asked if progress had been made, and Chair Tonya Rodriguez responded that it has moved "as much as it can move in the times of COVID right now."
During the brainstorming session for the 2021 Work Plan, Commissioner Daniel Young asked if the city could become the first in North Carolina to allow individuals with felony records to work with children in certain capacities. Staff member Brad clarified that the City of Asheville had previously eliminated the requirement to disclose felony records on employment applications.
Community Input
One emailed public comment was addressed during the meeting. The comment expressed concern that the board did not have the required two members representing the disability community. In response, Chair Tonya Rodriguez stated, "I’d like to add that not all disabilities can be seen." Staff member Brad clarified that he was not aware of any legal requirement for the board to include a specific number of persons with disabilities on its membership.
Follow-ups
Staff member Richard White agreed to look into the status of the Community Policing Advisory Committee (CPAC) and provide an update at the next meeting. He also agreed to email the schedule of upcoming equity-based budget workshops to the commission members and to share the contract for the consultant handling the search for the new Director of Equity and Inclusion. Richard White indicated that Rosanna from the Office of Equity and Inclusion is willing to come to the next meeting to present an update on the disparity study. Additionally, a member agreed to contact the organization "Beloved" to see if the commission could assume a role in handling recommendations for homeless encampments.
Impact
This meeting resulted in a formal recommendation to the City Council regarding the removal of the Vance Monument, a significant step in the city's ongoing discussions about public monuments and historical representation. The election of new leadership, with Tonya Rodriguez as Chair and Brandon Oliver as Vice Chair, establishes the commission's leadership for the upcoming year. The commission also began outlining its 2021 work plan, identifying key areas of focus such as policing, school equity, budget participation, and support for formerly incarcerated individuals. Staff updates on the Office of Equity and Inclusion highlight the ongoing challenges of staffing and the use of federal pandemic funds to support equity initiatives.
Meeting Video & Transcript