Historic Resources Commission
April 14, 2021 at 4:00 PM
- 3 h 6 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
On April 14, 2021, the City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission held a virtual meeting to review applications for historic properties, adopt a resolution, and present an award. The commission began by approving the minutes from its March 10 meeting unanimously. The agenda included evidentiary hearings for seven properties within historic districts, a request for a subdivision that was paused due to procedural objections, a resolution opposing demolition in the Chestnut Hill National Register District, and the presentation of the Historic Resources Champion Award.
The commission approved Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) for six of the seven property applications. For 410 Biltmore Plaza, the commission approved a new shed roof and patio; one commissioner recused themselves due to a professional relationship with the applicant, and the remaining members voted unanimously to approve and issue the COA. For 281 Pearson Drive, the commission approved new construction of a primary structure and an accessory dwelling unit (ADU). The approval included conditions requiring the submission of manufacturer specifications for materials, window colors, and a revised site plan for staff review. For 48 Patton Avenue (Drew Moore Building), the commission approved the repair and replacement of 46 wood windows; one commissioner recused themselves, and the remaining members voted unanimously to approve and issue the COA with no conditions. The commission also unanimously approved and issued COAs with no conditions for window and door modifications at 250 Montford Avenue and door replacements at 25 Starnes Avenue.
For 258 Cumberland Avenue (Road), the commission discussed the removal of a sunroom and the construction of an addition on a non-contributing structure. During the discussion, commissioners recommended changing the proposed awning windows to one-over-one double-hung windows to better match the existing architecture and reducing the size of the window bank to allow for more siding. The commission unanimously approved the COA with the condition that the selection of double-hung windows and revised elevation drawings be submitted to staff for approval.
The commission paused the hearing for 141 Cumberland Avenue, a request for a subdivision, after multiple public commenters objected to the virtual format of the meeting. The Deputy City Attorney advised that under state law, remote quasi-judicial hearings require the consent of all interested parties. Since objections were raised, the commission voted unanimously to recess the matter until it can be held in person or in a format agreed upon by the parties.
The commission also addressed a draft resolution presented by the Executive Director of the Preservation Society opposing the substantial demolition of 13 contributing structures in the Chestnut Hill National Register District as part of a proposed multi-use development at 101 Charlotte Street. The Executive Director stated that the demolition would result in a loss of the district’s integrity, possible reduction of district boundaries, and a loss of tangible connections to previous residents. The Deputy City Attorney clarified that while the commission is not obligated to pass the resolution, it is within their purview to comment on historic properties. The commission unanimously adopted the resolution, as amended, to oppose the demolition. The adopted resolution will be shared with City Council and Planning and Zoning Commission staff for consideration during the review of the development project.
Finally, the commission unanimously awarded the Historic Resources Champion Award to Mr. George Taylor (deceased) and Mr. George Gibson for their substantial work in maintaining the South Asheville Cemetery, a local historic landmark.
Staff member Alex Smith agreed to follow up with the applicants for 250 Montford Avenue, 25 Starnes Avenue, and 48 Patton Avenue early the following week. Staff also indicated they would follow up with the applicant for 258 Cumberland Avenue (Road) early the following week regarding the required window and elevation submissions. The applicant’s representative for 281 Pearson Drive stated that his contractor would email staff with outstanding specifications for doors, mechanical units, and patio materials, which staff confirmed would be reviewed after approval.
Meeting Video & Transcript