Historic Resources Commission
March 10, 2021 at 3:59 PM
- 5 h 9 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On March 10, 2021, the City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission (HRC) held a virtual meeting to review administrative business and conduct evidentiary hearings for Certificates of Appropriateness (CA). The commission adopted the minutes from its February 10, 2021 meeting, reviewed six development applications within historic districts, voted on the renaming of its annual preservation award, and addressed an attendance policy issue regarding a county-appointed seat.
Development Applications and Decisions The commission reviewed six requests for Certificates of Appropriateness, approving four and continuing two to a future meeting.
- 122 West Chestnut Street (Montford Historic District): The commission approved the CA for a new accessory dwelling unit (ADU) by a vote of 9 ayes. The approval included conditions requiring the submission of revised elevation drawings showing a change from porch brackets to posts, as well as stone samples and lap siding specifications.
- 10 Biltmore Plaza (Biltmore Village): The commission voted 9 ayes to continue the application to the April meeting. Commissioner Mitchell recused himself from this item due to a conflict of interest.
- 44 Watauga Street (Montford Historic District): The commission approved the CA for replacing a rear window and door with French doors by a vote of 9 ayes. The approval included the condition that the removed four-light window must be retained on the premises.
- 103 Pearson Drive (Montford Historic District): The commission unanimously approved the CA for new construction, including a house, porch, and site improvements. The approval included five conditions to be reviewed at the staff level, such as revised elevations, a revised site plan, and changes to walkway and railing materials.
- 37 Watauga Street (Montford Historic District): The commission unanimously approved the CA for swapping a first-floor porch door with a second-story door and replacing a rear window with French doors. The approval included the condition that the original rear window be retained and preserved on site.
- 281 Pearson Drive (Montford Historic District): The commission unanimously voted to continue the application for a new primary structure and detached ADU to the April meeting. No CA was issued at this time.
Administrative Actions and Policy The commission voted to formally rename the annual preservation award, previously known as the "Sondley Award," to the "Historic Resources Champion Award." The name received the most votes among the options considered. The commission resolved to retire the physical "Sondley Cup" artifact, with future recipients receiving a framed certificate instead. Additionally, the commission voted unanimously (5-0) to recommend that the seat of the county-appointed member be declared vacant due to failure to attend three consecutive regular meetings. Staff clarified that this vote serves as a recommendation to the County Commission, which holds the ultimate authority to appoint or remove the member.
Discussion Highlights During the review of 122 West Chestnut Street, staff expressed concern that the proposed porch design looked "tacked on" and suggested using posts instead of brackets. Chair Emily Kite noted that the HRC is a quasi-judicial body authorized to hear CA requests based on competent, material, and substantial evidence. For 10 Biltmore Plaza, staff and Commissioner Spring raised concerns that the proposed garage doors were out of character for the Biltmore Village district. Applicants requested a continuance to revise the design, including addressing the garage doors, skylights, and stair placement.
Regarding 103 Pearson Drive, staff noted that the proposed composite material (Trex) for the porch had not been previously approved by the commission and appeared "faux." An arborist present for the hearing explained that using pea gravel for the walkway would help protect the root system of a large sycamore tree on the property. Chair Kite stated she had no concerns about the structure itself, noting it was a "clever use of that narrow space."
For 281 Pearson Drive, staff and commissioners discussed the architectural style, with staff noting the design did not clearly read as a specific style. Commissioner Will Hornaday emphasized the integrity of the standard regardless of sight lines, and Chair Kite agreed that applying standards based on visibility could create future inconsistencies. Staff and Commissioner Ben Mitchell discussed the lack of recent precedent for exterior upper-level entrances to ADUs.
Follow-ups Staff agreed to review the revised elevations and materials for 122 West Chestnut Street, 103 Pearson Drive, and 281 Pearson Drive at the staff level. For 10 Biltmore Plaza, staff agreed to send a follow-up email to the applicants with notes from the meeting. Staff also agreed to draft a formal letter explaining the renaming of the award and to find a suitable location in City Hall to store the retired "Sondley Cup." Commissioner Will Hornaday offered to design a certificate template for the new award. Regarding the attendance policy, staff agreed to reach out to the head of the Boards and Commissions Committee to coordinate with the county on handling the vacancy. Chair Kite agreed to table the officer slate vote until the next meeting to allow for the circulation of nominations to an absent committee member.
Impact These decisions impact residents in the Montford Historic District and Biltmore Village by establishing precedents for the types of materials, architectural details, and accessory structures permitted in these areas. The approval of new construction and ADUs contributes to housing stock in the historic districts, while the conditions imposed ensure that new work remains consistent with the historic character of the neighborhoods. The renaming of the award and the recommendation to declare a county seat vacant reflect the commission’s ongoing efforts to update its recognition programs and maintain active participation from its appointed members.
Meeting Video & Transcript