Skip to main content

Planning & Zoning Commission

April 7, 2021 at 4:59 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Feb 5 meetingNext: May 5 meeting
  • 1 h 22 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On April 7, 2021, the City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a meeting to address five primary agenda items. The Commission began by approving the minutes from its February 3 and February 5 meetings. The remainder of the session focused on two public hearings—one quasi-judicial regarding a variance request and one legislative regarding a rezoning request—followed by the review of two administrative amendments to the city’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and the Commission’s own Rules of Procedure.

Key Decisions

The Commission took the following actions during the meeting:

  • Minutes: The motion to approve the minutes from the February 3 and February 5 meetings passed unanimously (7 Ayes).
  • Variance (175 Biltmore Avenue): The Commission approved a variance to Section 711.2 of the UDO for South Slope Investments LLC. The approval included a specific condition that the variance applies only to the adaptive reuse of the existing building and does not apply to any project that would demolish the existing structure for new construction, though reasonable modifications or additions to the existing structure are permitted. The vote was 6-1, with Commissioner Kimberly Levi voting Nay.
  • Rezoning (99999 Glendale Avenue): The Commission approved the rezoning of the property from Residential Multifamily High Density (RM16) to Commercial Industrial (CI). This decision included an amendment to the Future Land Use Map, changing the designation from "Traditional Neighborhood" to "Urban Corridor." The vote passed unanimously (7 Ayes).
  • UDO Amendments: The Commission approved amendments to Articles 3, 5, 6, and 7 of Chapter 7 of the UDO to ensure compliance with North Carolina General Statute Chapter 160D. The vote passed unanimously (7 Ayes).
  • Rules of Procedure: The Commission approved amendments to its own Rules of Procedure to align with 160D requirements. The vote was recorded as 5 Ayes, and the Chair stated the motion passed unanimously.

Discussion Highlights

During the quasi-judicial hearing for the Biltmore Avenue variance, Derek Allen, the petitioner’s agent, explained that the request seeks to continue using a publicly dedicated right-of-way for access to approximately 10-11 parking spaces, a configuration that has existed since at least 1998. Allen noted that maintaining the appearance of an operating parking lot helps discourage cut-through traffic and improves safety. Staff explained that while the UDO generally prohibits using rights-of-way for parking maneuvering for safety reasons, the existing use predates the current ordinance. Commissioner Brenton Faircloth stated he had no problem with continuing the current use but expressed a preference for closing the right-of-way entirely. Commissioner Jenifer Bubenik emphasized the importance of recording names and addresses of commenters to ensure the Commission considers those actually affected.

For the Glendale Avenue rezoning, staff supported the request because the property is a small "island" of residential zoning surrounded by commercial uses, and the change aligns with the Future Land Use Map. Rob Dahl of SiteWorks Studios, the presenter, explained that the current RM16 zoning creates 20-foot landscape buffers that dissect the acreage, creating barriers to development.

Regarding the 160D compliance amendments, Jannice Ashley, Deputy City Attorney, explained that the changes narrow quasi-judicial notice to adjacent properties only to avoid giving non-adjacent residents the impression that their comments affect the outcome when they lack standing. Ashley also noted that the amendments broaden the conflict of interest standard for planning-related boards. Staff member Shannon Tucker clarified that the intent of the 160D updates was to clarify, consolidate, and reorganize existing laws rather than change them dramatically.

Community Input

No members of the public spoke during the public comment periods for the variance, rezoning, or UDO amendment hearings. Staff confirmed there were no callers in the queue for each item, and the Chair closed the floor for comment immediately after opening it.

Follow-ups

Jannice Ashley, Deputy City Attorney, agreed to send the language for the variance order to Derek Allen, the petitioner’s agent, for review before drafting the final findings of fact and conclusions of law. Additionally, staff member Shannon Tucker offered to send a copy of the "Quasi-Judicial Handbook" to any new commissioners who did not receive one during training.

Impact

These decisions update the city’s regulatory framework to comply with state law and resolve specific land use requests. The 160D compliance amendments will change how the city handles public notice for quasi-judicial hearings, limiting broad notifications to adjacent properties to streamline the process and clarify standing. The variance for 175 Biltmore Avenue allows the continued use of a right-of-way for parking maneuvering, specifically tied to the adaptive reuse of the existing building. The rezoning of 99999 Glendale Avenue aligns the property’s zoning with its surrounding commercial neighbors and the city’s Future Land Use Map, removing the regulatory barriers created by the previous residential designation.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches