Skip to main content

Planning & Zoning Commission

February 5, 2021 at 8:59 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Feb 3 meetingNext: Apr 7 meeting
  • 31 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held a remote special meeting on February 5, 2021, to address unfinished business from a previous regular meeting. The session focused on four items related to zoning text and map amendments concerning hotels and residential development. No live public comment was taken during this special session, though written submissions were accepted and shared with the Commission.

The Commission voted on all four agenda items, resulting in two unanimous approvals and two split decisions. The first item, a zoning text amendment to align the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) with recent state legislation regarding discretionary decisions, passed unanimously with 6 ayes and 0 nays. The second item, a zoning text amendment establishing new standards for hotels—including definitions for small and large hotels, "great room" guest rooms, and a 20-year affordability period for density bonuses—passed 5-1. Commissioner Coon voted against the measure, while Commissioners Levi, Hoke, Rodriguez, Archibald, and Chair Hauser voted in favor.

The third item involved a zoning map amendment to apply a new hotel overlay district to specific properties within city limits. This motion included a condition to remove the property at 185 Clingman Avenue, known as the Gray Eagle property, from the overlay. The amendment passed 5-1, with Commissioner Archibald voting against and Commissioners Levi, Hoke, Rodriguez, Coon, and Chair Hauser voting in favor. Staff explained that the removal of the Gray Eagle property was in response to concerns from some council members that a small hotel might not be appropriate for that specific location. The fourth and final item was an initial zoning designation for a 0.47-acre parcel off Oak Hill Circle and Moore Crest Road. The Commission unanimously approved the preliminary designation of Residential Multi-Family High Density (RM16) and a future land use map designation of Traditional Neighborhood, with all six members voting aye.

During the discussion of the RM16 zoning item, the Commission reviewed written public comments. One resident expressed confusion regarding agenda language stating that groups of no more than three people could speak. Chair Hauser acknowledged the comment and stated that the language should be eliminated until the Commission moves back into physical meetings. Another resident raised concerns about traffic impacts, noting that projects falling below the threshold for a Traffic Impact Analysis often do not have these concerns addressed. Chair Hauser responded by suggesting that transportation would look at the matter more closely once there is a plan for a project, adding that developers benefit from the community and should contribute to maintaining a transportation system. Staff member Shannon Tuck clarified that the Commission was voting on preliminary zoning, not a specific development, and that the proposed zoning is consistent with the surrounding area.

Several commissioners offered notable statements on the hotel-related items. Commissioner Levi noted that the changes seem like a first step towards a design review commission for all projects in Asheville. Commissioner Coon expressed uncertainty about how the effectiveness of the new hotel ordinance will be gauged, questioning whether it would be measured by the return of hotel development or its absence. Commissioner Hoke expressed hope that the public benefits table included in the ordinance would serve as a blueprint for every large project in Asheville.

Regarding follow-up actions, Chair Hauser agreed to remove the language regarding "groups of no more than three" from future agendas until the Commission returns to in-person meetings. Staff member Shannon Tuck confirmed that all written public comments received for the RM16 item were shared with the Commission and added to the meeting folder. The next regular meeting is scheduled for March 3rd.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches