Skip to main content
  • 1 h 50 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: March 15, 2021

The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville convened on March 15, 2021, to address a variety of agenda items ranging from development compliance to urban forestry policy. The primary decision of the meeting was the denial of an alternative compliance request for a proposed office and studio building. The Commission also reviewed updates on the Open Space Amendment Task Force, the Asheville Tree Map, and the city’s budget request, while discussing the structure of its internal Policy Working Group.

Key Decisions The Commission voted to deny the Alternative Compliance Request for a 12,930-square-foot office/studio building at 76 Glendale Avenue. The request sought to reduce a required 20-foot buffer yard to 10 feet and decrease the number of required deciduous trees. The motion to deny passed with a vote of 6-1. Ayes were cast by Patrick Gilbert, Ed Macy, Sharon Summerall, Steve Hendrix, Cecil Bothwell, and Chair Amy Smith; Perrin DeJong voted nay. During the discussion, Steve Hendrix initially proposed an amendment to continue the item pending the outcome of a related zoning request but withdrew it after learning the applicant could still refine their plans if the request was denied. The meeting concluded with a unanimous 7-0 vote to adjourn.

Discussion Highlights Commission members debated the Glendale Avenue project, with Cecil Bothwell arguing that the need for a variance was "entirely created by the builder" and driven by the "desire for the maximum profit on this property." In defense of the project, Rob Doll, a Landscape Architect from SiteWorks Studios, stated that the development would bring mixed-use artist studios to the area and help "activate Glendale." Mike Wheeler, an Urban Planner from Development Services, clarified that the project was filed prior to the adoption of the tree canopy protection ordinance, meaning that specific ordinance did not apply.

Other discussions included an update from Perrin DeJong on the Open Space Amendment Task Force, which reported adopting a "consensus minus one" decision-making model. DeJong noted that the group had achieved agreement on this process. Members also reviewed a draft Commission mission statement, suggesting edits to explicitly include the social benefits of trees and equity. Regarding the Policy Working Group, the Commission noted the need for a chairperson and a separate meeting to define short-term goals.

The Commission also discussed the Asheville Tree Map, with Dawn Chavez describing it as a valuable educational tool for involving the public in urban forestry, despite existing data gaps. Mark Foster, the City Arborist, addressed challenges in tracking total trees planted across multiple departments, noting that at least one department has been providing information. The meeting also covered an update on the Tree Canopy Protection Ordinance Fee in Lieu process, with the city aiming to send the drafted policy and guidance map for review in April. Additionally, the Commission discussed a steep-slope grading violation case at 424 Sunset Drive, which is scheduled for the Board of Adjustment. Sharon Summerall expressed concern that a neighbor had only recently received a letter and lacked the specific details needed to argue the case intelligently.

Community Input No public comments were recorded during the open public comment period. The Chair confirmed that no written or verbal public comments had been received for the agenda items.

Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff member Hayley Mahoney noted that January meeting minutes were missing from the folder but are ready; the Commission agreed to approve both the January minutes and the current meeting’s minutes at the next meeting on April 6. Ed Macy agreed to schedule a separate meeting for the policy working group to develop a list of priorities and timelines. City Staff member Ben agreed to send the previous year’s budget request documents to Chair Amy Smith by the next day, with the Commission agreeing to review these documents offline via email and provide updated talking points to Ben by the end of March. Chair Amy Smith agreed to include the link to the Asheville Tree Map in future meeting minutes and agendas. Finally, Zoning Coordinator Ricky Hurley stated that the Board of Adjustment packet for the 424 Sunset Drive case would be posted late Thursday or early Friday and offered to email the link to the neighbor who expressed concern about transparency.

Impact These decisions and discussions reflect the Commission’s ongoing role in balancing development with urban forestry goals. The denial of the Glendale Avenue buffer reduction maintains existing tree protection standards for that specific site. The focus on the Tree Map and unified planting data aims to improve public education and internal tracking of the city’s tree inventory. The review of the budget request and the formation of the Policy Working Group indicate continued efforts to secure resources and define strategic priorities for urban forestry in Asheville.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches