Urban Forestry Commission
January 19, 2021 at 3:30 PM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: January 19, 2021
The City of Asheville’s Urban Forestry Commission convened on January 19, 2021, to address routine approvals, project updates, and strategic initiatives regarding reforestation and environmental justice. The meeting opened with the introduction of Amy Smith as the new Chair of the Commission. The agenda included discussions on the Open Space Amendment, tree canopy preservation, and the commission’s operational structure, including its mission statement and meeting schedules.
Key Decisions The Commission approved the minutes from the previous meeting by roll call, with all members voting "Aye." Regarding the Haw Creek Elementary reforestation project, the Vice Chair presented a working group recommendation to select "Option 2," which involves waiting until winter/spring 2022 so the school district pays the full cost, rather than starting immediately with partial funding. This recommendation was accepted without a formal vote or objection. The Commission also reaffirmed its standing motion opposing the Open Space Amendment as drafted. The Chair noted that while a working group will continue negotiations with city staff, the formal position of opposition remains until more concrete information is received from the city. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which passed by roll call with all members voting "Aye."
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on urban reforestation and environmental justice. Staff reported on a $50,000 grant from the Gannett Foundation awarded to Asheville GreenWorks for tree planting in marginalized communities affected by urban renewal and redlining. Commissioner Ed Macy advocated for the Commission to pursue the American Forests Environmental Equity Index, stating, "I think it’s worth pursuing [the American Forests index], certainly... I have the sense that it might help us tell a story if we have American Forest behind us."
Staff Nancy Watford provided an update on the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance, detailing enforcement tracking and staff training with GreenWorks. She also reported on the development of a report to track canopy preservation, planting, and fee-in-lieu metrics. In a separate enforcement matter, staff Ricky Hurley updated the Commission on a steep-slope development violation at 424 Sunset Drive, noting the case may need to return to the Board of Adjustment.
The Commission also discussed its composition, specifically the attendance of ex officio members from Duke Energy, MSD, and GreenWorks. The Chair stated she will reach out to these entities to encourage attendance; if unsuccessful, the Commission will consider revising the ordinance. Additionally, the Chair and a member agreed to form a working group to explore collaboration with the Historic Resource Commission on designating "historic trees." City Staff Chris Collins and TRC Representative Sharon Summerall discussed the Commission’s role in early-stage development reviews for conditional zoning projects, with Summerall emphasizing the need for arborist reports to demonstrate genuine efforts to save trees.
Community Input Two written public comments were addressed during the meeting. First, a resident expressed concern over the proposed sale of a city-owned parcel on Ashland Avenue, originally a buffer park, for a four-story apartment complex, fearing the loss of trees and green space. The Chair clarified that the deed restriction cited by the commenter was invalid due to an attachment error and a 1993 expiration date. Staff confirmed the project is exempt from the urban renewal moratorium as it was already under discussion. The Chair outlined next steps, including a City Council work session on January 26 and a vote on the sale on February 23, and staff confirmed that if development proceeds, it will trigger canopy requirements.
Second, a resident suggested including native edible trees in city planting plans to support wildlife and community connection to food. The Chair confirmed that native species are a priority and that edible species are included in the recommended list. Staff noted that Asheville GreenWorks includes edible species in their giveaways and directed staff to include this information in the reply to the commenter.
Follow-ups Several action items were assigned during the meeting. Staff will provide updated information on the deed restriction status for the Ashland Avenue project, and the Chair will monitor the project’s progress through City Council. A member will contact the American Forests representative to schedule a call within the next month to discuss the communication phase of the Environmental Equity Index. Council Liaison Kim Roney stated she will update the group when more information is available regarding the next steps for a reparations commission.
Regarding the 424 Sunset Drive enforcement case, staff Ricky Hurley stated he would email the contractor to confirm final grading square footage and agreed to speak with management about reissuing a notice of violation for tree removal. Staff Nancy Watford agreed to provide monthly updates on the Tree Canopy Preservation Ordinance. The Chair will send a scheduling poll to determine the date and time for the upcoming virtual planning retreat, aiming for late February or early March, and will reach out to ex officio members regarding attendance. Staff will circulate a poll to confirm a change to the regular meeting time, likely to the first Tuesday of the month at 1:00 PM, to accommodate the Council Liaison. Additionally, staff is drafting a Rules and Procedures Manual to guide commission operations and will seek member feedback once a draft is ready.
Impact These discussions and decisions highlight the Commission’s focus on balancing development with environmental stewardship and equity. The reaffirmation of opposition to the Open Space Amendment and the detailed review of the Ashland Avenue parcel sale underscore the Commission’s role in scrutinizing land use decisions that affect tree canopy and public green space. The pursuit of the American Forests Environmental Equity Index and the partnership with Asheville GreenWorks on the Gannett Foundation grant demonstrate a commitment to addressing historical disparities in tree coverage. Furthermore, the operational changes, including the formation of a working group on historic trees and the revision of meeting schedules, aim to strengthen the Commission’s effectiveness and community engagement.
Meeting Video & Transcript