Historic Resources Commission
January 13, 2021 at 4:00 PM
- 3 h 48 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Historic Resources Commission held a virtual meeting on January 13, 2021. The agenda included the adoption of previous minutes and the review of four applications for Certificates of Appropriateness (CA): three within the Montford Historic District (122 West Chestnut Street, 250 Montford Avenue, and 81 Courtland Avenue) and one for the Asheville City Hall elevator modernization.
Key Decisions
The Commission unanimously adopted the minutes from the December 9, 2020 meeting, including findings of fact and conclusions of law. Following extensive discussion, the Commission voted to continue the applications for 122 West Chestnut Street, 250 Montford Avenue, and 81 Courtland Avenue to the February 10, 2021 meeting; all three continuations passed unanimously.
For the Asheville City Hall elevator modernization, the Commission voted 6-1 to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness. The motion included findings that the application met Secretary of the Interior standards for rehabilitation, retaining historic character where possible while replacing hazardous or non-compliant elements. The Commission subsequently voted 6-1 to issue the CA with specific conditions, requiring staff to ensure the elevators are documented for public benefit, confirming flooring colors, and verifying cab dimensions.
Discussion Highlights
Significant debate occurred regarding the 122 West Chestnut Street accessory structure, which staff and Commissioners noted exceeds the 30% size guideline relative to the primary building. Concerns were raised that the structure is too tall, visually competes with the primary historic building—a Richard Sharpe Smith design—and alters site topography through excavation. Staff suggested simplifying windows and using lap siding to match the primary structure.
For 81 Courtland Avenue, the central issue was off-street parking placement. While Montford guidelines generally prohibit front-yard parking, exceptions exist if the rear yard is inaccessible due to slope or insufficient depth. Staff and Commissioners debated whether the steep topography of the newly subdivided lot justified front-yard parking, with some concerned about setting a precedent. Staff suggested narrowing the 18-foot driveway apron to a standard width and using less harsh materials than concrete.
The most extensive debate concerned the Asheville City Hall elevator modernization, balancing the retention of historic features (brass doors, call plates, cab interiors) with ADA compliance and life safety. The plan involves replacing original brass doors containing asbestos and removing mercury switch gear. A proposal to keep one elevator operational as a "showpiece" or mothball it was rejected by experts due to liability, code violations, and mechanical impracticality. John Toller of United Elevator Services stated that keeping the machines running is "not practical" and that the liability is "really high." Sean Bowman of Weaver Cook noted that leaving old equipment would "not pass current day code." Chair Emily Kite agreed, stating, "I don't see a practical pathway to that."
Follow-ups
Staff and applicants agreed to several follow-up actions. For 122 West Chestnut Street, the applicant agreed to revise plans to reduce porch scale, integrate the porch into the roofline, simplify windows, and potentially move the structure to align with the historic footprint. Staff agreed to make the paint palette a condition of approval. For 81 Courtland Avenue, the applicant agreed to work with the architect to refine the parking solution, potentially narrowing the driveway or considering on-street parking.
Regarding the City Hall elevators, staff confirmed that a video documentary and photographic archive are already in progress and agreed to share the final product with the Commission and post it on the city website. Staff also agreed to discuss offline where the removed brass gates and mechanical parts will be stored or displayed, with the goal of keeping them accessible to the public, and to bring potential display ideas back to the Commission. Additionally, the Chair asked members to bring ideas for the new name of the "Soundly Award" and thoughts on its format to the next meeting.
Impact
This meeting resulted in the approval of the modernization of the three elevators at Asheville City Hall, a significant preservation and safety project. The decision ensures that hazardous materials, including asbestos and mercury, are removed while documenting the historic mechanical systems for public benefit. The continuance of the three Montford District applications allows for further design refinement to ensure new construction respects the historic character of the neighborhood, particularly regarding scale, massing, and parking standards.
Meeting Video & Transcript