Design Review Committee of Downtown Commission
January 13, 2021 at 11:00 AM
- 55 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On January 13, 2021, the Design Review Committee of the Downtown Commission met to review the second presentation for the Four Points Sheridan Project, a major mixed-use development proposed for the intersection of Woodfin and Central Avenue. The project includes a hotel, condominiums, retail space, and a parking garage. The design team from MHA Works presented refined renderings focusing on the building’s exterior materials, massing, and streetscape integration. The committee’s role is to provide collaborative feedback to developers to improve design before the project moves to the full Downtown Commission; consequently, no formal votes were taken during this session.
Discussion Highlights A primary focus of the discussion was the building’s massing and materials. The design team proposed breaking the large structure into four distinct elements using masonry, metal panels, and manufactured stone to avoid a monolithic appearance. However, committee members noted that the current design reads as horizontally banded, visually tying the separate blocks together. Committee member Brian Moffitt suggested introducing vertical elements to better distinguish the different building sections, particularly the block containing the hotel pre-function space. Committee member Robin Raines expressed similar concerns, noting that the horizontal banding makes the sections appear to share the same floor line. Committee Chair Steven Lee Johnson spoke in strong support of on-street parking along Woodfin Avenue, citing existing crosswalk opportunities and the success of on-street parking near the YMCA as a model.
Staff and committee members also emphasized the importance of the Central Avenue streetscape, identifying it as a critical pedestrian and bicycle corridor connecting North Asheville to downtown. Staff member Shannon noted that the current "blank wall" facade on this side requires improved treatment, including potential granite curbs and better tree planting systems to support tree health in the hot, south-facing environment. Regarding the existing hotel structure on the site, the design team explained that it would be clad in a lighter material, such as EFIS or metal panel, because the existing foundation cannot support heavy brick masonry.
Community Input One written public comment was submitted regarding parking management. The commenter inquired how parking would be managed given the limited space around the YMCA and Renaissance Hotel, specifically asking about transient parking for the Earth Fare grocery store and how to prevent overflow from the YMCA and hotel. Peter Albariz of MHA Works responded that all residential units will have at least one structured parking space. He stated that while the team recognizes the need for downtown parking, they currently feel the on-site parking is sufficient for the complex's uses, and that building additional leasable parking had been discussed internally but was not part of the current plan.
A late-arriving comment, which was not officially entered into the record, was read aloud by staff. It asked if the building mass could be moved to the east side of the site to keep the entire site below 75 feet and requested more activation of Central Avenue. The design team explained that moving the mass to the highway side was considered early on but rejected because it would create undesirable living spaces for residents facing the highway. They confirmed that the major portion of the building’s height has not changed from the previous meeting, though they are still refining the height of the restaurant section near the highway.
Follow-ups The design team agreed to several specific follow-up actions based on the committee’s feedback. They committed to looking into adding vertical elements to the building facade to better separate the different building blocks and address the "horizontal" feel of the current design. Additionally, the team agreed to address the "blank wall" on the Central Avenue side, including improving the streetscape interaction and looking into the specific treatment of the existing hotel facade and pedestrian access. The team also confirmed that they have initiated a parking study required by the Traffic Review Committee, which will provide data on traffic flow and potential on-street parking accommodations along Woodfin Avenue.
Impact This review is significant for residents as it addresses the design of a major development at a key intersection in downtown Asheville. The feedback provided by the committee and staff aims to ensure the project integrates better with the surrounding neighborhood, particularly by improving the pedestrian experience on Central Avenue and distinguishing the building’s massing to avoid a monolithic appearance. The design team indicated they will present a third and final design review meeting before the formal Downtown Commission meeting, where they will have addressed the feedback regarding Central Avenue and verticality.
Meeting Video & Transcript