Skip to main content

Downtown Design Review Committee

February 5, 2021 at 11:30 AM

  • 42 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On February 5, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Downtown Design Review Committee held a design review session for the Four Points Sheraton project located at the intersection of Woodfin and Central Avenue. This was the third meeting for this project, during which the design team presented a 3D model illustrating updates made in response to previous feedback. The session focused on refining the building’s massing, materials, and infrastructure to better integrate with the downtown streetscape.

Key Decisions No formal motions were made, and no votes were taken during this meeting. The session served as a design review where the committee provided feedback to the design team rather than making final approvals or rejections.

Discussion Highlights The committee and design team discussed several specific aspects of the project’s continued development. Regarding the Woodfin Street facade, the team presented changes to narrow the street to allow for on-street parking, expand landscaping, and include a retail space at the corner. Discussion also covered the articulation of window openings and balconies. For the Central Avenue side, the design team proposed a structured plaza deck with an end wall to ensure security while avoiding a "blank wall" appearance, incorporating stepped landscaping elements.

Building massing and materials were central to the debate, with a focus on using a consistent masonry base to tie different building blocks together. Committee members raised concerns about the proportions of a red/orange brick section, noting it appeared "squatty." Robin Raines, the Committee Chair, stated, "I still want it to have a cap on... or be a little taller or something different with the scale above of the brick portion... To me, it feels like the amount of brick above the top window feels squatty to me." Additionally, Brian Moffitt, a committee member, expressed concern about blank walls, asking, "I keep getting you on these blank walls... programmatically, what's behind that? ... I would like for you to think about this one a little bit more."

Traffic and infrastructure discussions included the relocation of curb cuts, specifically moving the main entrance away from the I-240 ramp. Warren, a staff member from the Community Development Department, noted, "We got some good feedback from city transportation as well as some DOT on locations of all these entry points... everybody's sort of been in agreement that we can move... that main entrance, more fitting with standard driveway entrances." The design team also explained that the courtyard would be a secure outdoor space with a small pool, necessitating walls that limit public access from the street.

Community Input Public comments were read aloud by staff, generally expressing concern about the project's scale and height. Commenters asked for the exact elevation of the condo building roof, the location of loading and trash collection areas, the location of rooftop equipment, and raised concerns that traffic studies conducted during the pandemic might not reflect pre-pandemic conditions.

In response, the design team stated they would need to check their model to provide the exact roof elevation data, noting that all elevations are based on mean sea level. Regarding trash collection, the design team explained they are considering an internal system accessed from the existing parking lot. The team confirmed that rooftop equipment will be screened, noting this is a requirement for all downtown projects. Warren, the staff member, stated that the team is "on top of" the traffic issues and takes all considerations into account. Brian Moffitt added that Woodfin Street is currently underutilized and can handle more traffic, supporting the density of the project.

Follow-ups The design team, represented by Peter Albreese, agreed to look into aligning the upper planes of two adjacent building elements to better join them visually, as suggested by a committee member. Additionally, the design team agreed to extend the parapet on the red brick building to 42 inches to allow for safe equipment maintenance and to accommodate a more substantial cap, addressing the concern about the "squatty" appearance. A committee member, Sasha, noted that they would need to re-read the code regarding the length of building mass over 75 feet facing Woodfin to ensure compliance.

Impact This meeting represents a step in the iterative design process for a significant development in the downtown area. By addressing specific concerns regarding building scale, street-level activation, and traffic flow, the committee is working to ensure the project integrates with the existing urban fabric. The feedback provided on massing and materials aims to prevent the building from appearing monolithic or disconnected from the surrounding streetscape, while the discussion on traffic infrastructure seeks to mitigate potential impacts on local road capacity.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches